Gender and class tensions between psychiatric nurses and the general nursing profession in mid-twentieth century New Zealand

Kate Prebble
Research Fellow, Centre for Mental Health Research, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand

Linda Bryder
Department of History, University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand

PP: 181 - 195

Abstract

Histories of twentieth century nursing usually present ‘general nursing' as the norm and make the assumption that nursing was a female-dominated profession in which men were a marginalised minority.

In this article, we argue that in New Zealand, psychiatric nursing had developed a distinct culture from general nursing, was more an occupation than a profession, and was one in which men held a central and powerful position.

We explore the tensions that developed between male psychiatric nurses (attendants) and professional nursing leaders when general nursing began to gain authority over mental hospital nursing in the period 1939 to 1959. We argue that rather than being marginalised, the male nurses used their strength as unionised, working-class men to resist the incremental control by general nursing, a profession underpinned by middle-class values. Some battles were lost, but overall the men retained a powerful position in the mental health system during this period.

| More

Keywords

nursing, nursing history, psychiatric nursing, male nursing, gender, New Zealand

View references

References

Appendices to the Journals of the House of Representatives (AJHR) (1909), H-22: 9.

Brunton W (2001) ‘A choice of difficulties': National Mental Health Policy in New Zealand, 1840-1947, PhD Thesis, University of Otago, New Zealand.

Cameron F (1957) Draft letter for Minister of Health, 08 October, H-1, 33374, 2/1/2, Archives New Zealand (ANZ),Wellington.

Cameron F (1958) to Margaret Pickard, NZRNA General Secretary, 10 September, NZNO Records, 79-032-02/06, ATL, Wellington.

Cameron F (1959) to Minister of Health, 06 July, H-1, 33374, 2/1/2, ANZ, Wellington.

Department of Mental Hospitals (1945) Circular, June, H-MHD, 1, 8/94/0, Vol 1, ANZ, Wellington, New Zealand.

Digby D (1985) Madness, Morality and Medicine: A Study of the York Retreat, Cambridge, UK.

Gittins D (1998) Madness in its Place: Narratives of Severalls Hospital, 1913-1997, London, UK.

Gray T (1937) to Public Service Commissioner, 26 January, H-MHD, 1, 8/125, ANZ, Wellington.

Gray T (1941) to Minister of Health, 22 April, H-MHD, 1, 8/125, ANZ, Wellington.

Hopton J (1997) ‘Daily Life in a Twentieth Century Psychiatric Hospital: An Oral History of Prestwich Hospital', International History of Nursing Journal 2(3): 27-39.

Hunter Williams W (1987) Out of Mind Out of Sight: The Story of Porirua Hospital, Porirua, pp.141-152.

Hutchinson CP (1972) Differential Pay Scale for Psychiatric and Psychopaedic Nurses: First Report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into Hospital and Related Services, Wellington.

Lambie M (1948) Report on Nursing Staff - Mental Hospitals, 25 August 1948, H-1, 33430, 1/11/ 77, ANZ, Wellington.

Lewis R (1957) to medical superintendents, 30 July, DAHI, Acc D266, 357j, file 6/26/6, ANZ, Dunedin.

Lewis R (1958a) to Nurses & Midwives Board, 22 July, H-MHD, 1, 8/94/0, Vol 2,ANZ, Wellington.

Lewis R (1958b) to N&MB, 28 July, H-MHD, 1, 8/94/0, Vol 2, ANZ, Wellington.

Long D (1961) Submission attached to memo to Director of Mental Hygiene: 29 May, H-1, 31000, 30/7/6, ANZ, Wellington.

MacLean H (1932) Nursing in New Zealand. History and Reminiscences, Wellington, New Zealand, p.52.

Mason R (1960) 11 August, H-1, 33374, 2/1/2, ANZ, Wellington.

Miers M (2000) Gender Issues in Nursing, Macmillan, Houndsmills, pp.88-89.

New Zealand Nursing Journal, Kai Tiaki (KT) (1909) 2(3) July: 77.

New Zealand Nursing Journal, Kai Tiaki (KT) (1940) 33(3): 84.

New Zealand Public Service List (NZPSL) (1939) Supplement to the New Zealand Gazette.

New Zealand Public Service List (NZPSL) (1949) Supplement to the New Zealand Gazette.

Prebble C (2007) ‘Ordinary Men and Uncommon Women:A History of Psychiatric Nursing in New Zealand Public Mental Hospitals, 1939 to 1972', PhD thesis, Auckland, New Zealand.

Public Service Association (PSA) (1945) ‘Claim for Attendant Staff and Hall Porters', 14 May, p.2, H, 1, 31097, Archives New Zealand (ANZ), Wellington, New Zealand.

Public Service Association (PSA) (1957a) Letter to Attorney General, in General Secretary Circular to members (26 July), Minutes of PSA Mental Health Group, 1956-1958, 82-046-031/5, Alexander Turnbull Library, (ATL),Wellington, New Zealand.

Public Service Association (PSA) (1957b) letter to Attorney General cited in: 26 July 1957, General Secretary, circular to members, Minutes of PSA Mental Health Group, 1956-1958, 82-046- 031/5, ATL, Wellington.

Public Service Journal (PSJ) (1939) 26(11): 692.

Public Service Journal (PSJ) (1946) 33: 9 and 398.

Public Service Journal (PSJ) (1947) 34(2): 47.

Public Service Journal (PSJ) (1949) 36: 37.

Ritchie TR (1948) Director-General of Health to John Russell, 24 August, H-MHD, 1, 8/94/0, Vol. 2, ANZ, Wellington.

Rodgers J (1987) ‘...A good nurse ... a good woman': Duty and Obedience in Early New Zealand Nursing Education, Reinterpreting the Educational Past. Essays in the History of New Zealand Education, Wellington, New Zealand Council for Educational Research.

Rothman D (1985) The Enduring Asylum; in Brown P (ed) Mental Health Care and Policy, Boston, pp.41-69.

Russell J (1945) to medical superintendents, 16 November, H-MHD, 1, 8/94/0 Vol. 1,ANZ, Wellington.

Russell J (1949) to Secretary, N&M Board, 28 January, H-MHD, 1, 8/116/8,ANZ, Wellington.

Sargison P (2001) Essentially a Woman's Work: A History of General Nursing in New Zealand, 1830-1930, PhD thesis, University of Otago, New Zealand.

Turnbull J (1957) to Minister of Health, 1 October, H-1, 33374, 2/1/2, ANZ, Wellington.

Turnbull J (1959) to Prime Minister, 11 May 1959, H-1, 33374, 2/1/2, ANZ, Wellington.

Navigate: Archives | Contents | Top of page

Sign Me Up

*Email Address
First Name
Surname

Web Feed

Latest Articles

Special Issues

Indigenous Health Care (2nd edn)
Volume 37/1

Nursing Workforce and Workplaces
Volume 36/1
Summary

Modeling of Clinical Nursing Care
Volume 35/1
Summary

Advances in Contemporary Mental Health Nursing – Second Edition
Volume 34/2
Summary

Advances in Contemporary Nursing and Gender
Volume 33/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Nurse Education
Volume 32/1-2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Nursing: History of Nursing and Midwifery in Australasia
Volume 30/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Transcultural Nursing: Pathways to Cultural Awareness (2nd edn)
Volume 28/1-2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Palliative and Supportive Care
Volume 27/1
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Aged Care: Retirement to End of Life
Volume 26/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary General Practice Nursing: Role of the Practice Nurse
Volume 26/1
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Nurse Recruitment and Retention: Problems and Challenges in Human Capacity Development
Volume 24/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Community and Family Health Care
Volume 23/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Indigenous Health Care (1st edn)
Volume 22/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Nursing and Interpersonal Violence
Volume 21/2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Mental Health Nursing (1st edn)
Volume 21/1
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Child and Family Care
Volume 18/1-2
Summary | Contents

Advances in Contemporary Transcultural Nursing (1st edn)
Volume 15/3
Summary | Contents



Website by Arrowsmith Websites. Business, Government & Corporate Websites, Web Hosting, Domain Names & SEO. Maleny, Sunshine Coast, Australia.