Measuring the workload of community mental health nurses: A review of the literature
Julie Henderson
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Flinders University, Bedford Park SA
Eileen Willis
Department of Palliative and Supportive Services, School of Medicine, Flinders University, Adelaide SA
Bonnie Walter
School of Nursing & Midwifery, Flinders University, Adelaide SA
Luisa Toffoli
Sydney Nursing School, University of Sydney, Sydney NSW
PP: 32
Abstract
The movement away from centralised awards along with the intensification of nursing work has provided an impetus for the Australian Nursing Federation to seek the inclusion of workload measurement tools into Enterprise Bargaining Agreements. This paper reports a review of literature undertaken to identify issues relating to workload measures developed for community mental health settings.
The issues addressed include:a review of approaches to measuring workload; an evaluation of how applicable these approaches are to community mental health settings; a review of issues that need to be considered in applying a workload measurement tool to community mental health; and the identification of existing workload models for this setting.
The paper concludes that activity based models which measure the work undertaken retrospectively are most appropriate for community mental health as they capture the less tangible aspects of community mental health nursing practice.
Keywords
community mental health, workload measures, case management, literature review, nursing, work intensification
References
Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2008) About Awards and Agreements. Accessed at: http://www.airc.gov.au/awards/about.htm on 17 January 2008.
Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2001) Nurses (South Australian Public Sector) Enterprise Agreement 2001, Federal Industrial Relations Commission, Adelaide, Commonwealth Government Printer.
Australian Industrial Relations Commission (2000) The Canberra Hospital Nursing Staff Agreement 1999-2001, Federal Industrial Relations Commission, Canberra, Commonwealth Government Printer.
Begley C, Brady A, Byrne G, Macgregor C, Griffith C and Horan P (2004) A Study of the Role and Workload of the Public Health Nurse in the Galway Community Care Area. The University of Dublin, Dublin.
Bower P, Jerrim S and Gask L (2004) Primary mental health workers: role expectations, conflict and ambiguity, Health and Social Care in the Community 12: 336-345.
Burns S (2003) Caseload profiling - a district nurse perspective, Primary Health Care 13: 36-38.
Byron A and McCathie H (1998) Casemix: The allied health response, Medical Journal of Australia 169: S46-47.
Cleak H (2002) A model of social work classification in health care, Australian Social Work 55: 38-49.
Cleary M, Walter G and Hunt G (2005) The experiences and views of mental health nurses regarding nursing care delivery in an integrated inpatient setting, International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 14: 72-77.
Commonwealth of Australia (1996) Workplace Relations Act, Act No 86 of 1988, Commonwealth Government of Australia, Canberra, Government Printer.
Diers D (1999) Casemix and nursing, Australian Health Review 22: 56-68.
Eaton J (2001) Safe Caseload Management, Professional Development Committee, The British Dietetic Association, Birmingham.
Fergusson-Pare M (2004) ACEN Position Statement: Nursing workload a priority for healthcare, Nursing Leadership 17: 24-26.
Gibb H, Livesey L and Zyla W (2003) At 3am who the hell do you call? Case management issues in sole practice as a rural community mental health nurse, Australasian Psychiatry 11: S127-130.
Goldstone L, Wing S, Barker L and Hughes A (2000) But who will make the visits? A patient-related information system for management in district nursing, Health Informatics Journal 6: 39-44.
Health and Community Services Union (HACSU) (2005) The Systematic Workload Implementation Model (SWIM), HACSU, Melbourne.
Henderson J, Willis E, Walter B and Toffoli L (2008) Community mental health nursing: Keeping pace with care delivery? International Journal of Mental Health Nursing, in press.
Horsell M (1996a) South Australian nursing service weights project in Nursing Branch Metropolitan Health Services Division SAHC (eds) Nursing and Case-Mix. Nursing Branch Metropolitan Health Services Division, South Australian Health Commission, Balyana Conference Centre.
Horsell M (1996b) Nursing Service Weights Project Version 3 AN-DRG, South Australian Health Commission Nursing Branch and Casemix Unit Project, Adelaide.
Johnston S, Salkeld G, Sanderson K, Issadikas C, Teeson M and Bulrich N (1998) Intensive case management: A cost effectiveness analysis, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 32: 551-559.
King R, Le Bas J and Spooner D (2000) The impact of caseload on the personal efficacy of mental health case managers, Psychiatric Services 51: 364-368.
King R, Meadows G and Le Bas J (2004) Compiling a caseload index for mental health case management, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 38: 455-462.
Meldrum L and Yellowlees P (2000) The measurement of a case manager's workload burden, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 34: 658-663.
Morris-Yates A and Andrew G (1997) Local Area Information Systems for Mental Health Services: General Principles and Guidelines. Developing Outcomes-Orientated Information Systems for Mental Health. Commonwealth Department of Health and Family Services, Canberra.
Muir-Cochrane E (2001) The case management practices of community mental health nurses: Doing the best we can, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Mental Health Nursing 10: 210-220.
Naji SA, Atherton-Naji A, McPherson I and Dow I (1998) The role of the community psychiatric nurse in community care: A national survey of present practice, Health Bulletin 56: 813-821.
Nolan P, Haque M, Bourke P and Dyke R (2004) A comparison of the work and values of community mental health nurses in two mental health NHS trusts, Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 11: 525-533.
O'Brien A, Abas M, Christensen J, Nicholls T, Prou T, Hekau A and Vanderpyl J (2002) Nursing Workload Measurement in Acute Mental Health Inpatient Units, Health Research Council of New Zealand, Auckland.
Simpson A (2005) Community psychiatric nurses and care coordinator role: Squeezed to provide limited nursing, Journal of Advanced Nursing 52: 689-699.
Smith L and Newton R (2007) Systematic review of case management, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 41: 2-9.
Stanton P (2000) Employment relationships in Victoria public hospitals: the Kennett years, Australian Health Review 23: 193-200.
Storfjell J, Allen C and Easley C (1997) Analysis and management of home health nursing caseloads and workloads, Journal of Nursing Administration 27: 24-33.
Wallace T, O'Connell S and Frisch S (2005) Community Psychiatric Practice: What do nurses do when they take to the streets? An analysis of Psychiatric and Mental Health nursing interventions in the community. Community Mental Health Journal 41: 481-496.
Ward M, Armstrong C, Lelliot P and Davies M (1999) Training skills and caseloads of community mental health support workers involved in case management: Evaluation from the initial UK demonstration sites, Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 6: 187-97.
Willis E (2002) Benchmarking working time in health care: the case of Excelcare, Australian Health Review 25: 134–140.
Zeeman Z, Chapman R, Wynaden D, Lewis M, Austin J and Finn M (2002) Community mental health care: Documenting the role of the nurse, Contemporary Nurse 12: 112-23.
Ziguras S and Stuart G (2000) A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of mental health case management over 20 years, Psychiatric Services 51: 1410-1421.
eContent Home
