Archives
Nursing their way not our way: Working with vulnerable and marginalised populations
Denise Wilson
Senior Lecturer in Nursing (Maori Health), School of Health Sciences, Albany Campus Coordinator, Massey University, Auckland; Fellow of the College of Nurses Aotearoa, New Zealand
Stephen Neville
Senior Lecturer, Faculty of Health Sciences, Massey University, Albany Campus, Auckland, New Zealand
Abstract
Aims and objectives
This paper uses the findings of two studies to explore the nature of nurses' practice when working with vulnerable and marginalised populations, particularly with regard to the attributes of holism and individualised care. A secondary analysis of the findings of two separate studies was undertaken, one on the elderly with delirium and the other with indigenous Māori women.
Background
Often considered vulnerable and marginalised, elderly and indigenous experiences of health services are often fraught with their health needs not always identified or addressed. Nursing claims that holism and individualised care are pivotal attributes underpinning nursing practice. However, the secondary analysis of two research studies highlight how vulnerable and marginalised populations accessing health and nursing services experience needs that are neither acknowledged nor integrated into intervention and treatment plans.
Design
A secondary analysis of one study with the elderly with delirium used a critical gerontological methodology informed by postmodernism and Foucault's understanding of discourse. The other study with indigenous Māori women utilised Glaserian grounded theory informed by a Maori-centred methodology.
Methods
The research on the elderly with delirium analysed 20 data sources, including interviews with older persons who had experienced delirium, members of their families and health professionals. The research with 38 indigenous Maori women aged between 24 and 65 years, inductively analysed interview data using constant comparative analysis, theoretical sampling and saturation of the core categories to generate a substantive grounded theory.
Results
The findings of each study showed that a problem focussed approach to health care is offered to patients that does not incorporate individual health experiences. In addition, the social context integral to people's lives outside of the health care environment is ignored and as such the very foundations of nursing practice, that of holism, is merely a rhetorical construct.
Conclusions
Vulnerable and marginalised patients experience care that neglects their perceived health needs and the realities of their life circumstances.
Relevance to Clinical Practice
Individualised care that extends beyond the presenting issue is vital, but raises challenges when working with those population groups considered vulnerable and marginalised to improve outcomes of their health experience.
Keywords
individualised care, patient-centred care, holism, vulnerable, indigenous patient care, elderly patient care, marginalised
References
Allan JD and Hall BA (1998) Challenging the focus of technology: a critique of the medical model in a changing health care system. Advances in Nursing Science 10: 546-554.
Atherton L, Stepney J, Hamilton J and Smart B (2004) Care of the homeless: a nurse-run PMS. Practice Nursing 15: 114-117.
Bishop R (1994) Initiating empowering research. New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies 29: 175-188.
Bourdelais P, James L, Blaikie A, Gutmann M and Hacker D (2005) International seminar on vulnerable populations: Definitions, categories and empirical analysis organized by the IUSSP Scientific Community on Historical Demography and the Ecoli Des Hautes Etutes en Social Science (EHESS), accessed at www.vulnerability.se/files/Vulnerable_Populations.pdf on 9 August 2006.
Boyd CM, Darer J, Boult C, Fried LP, Boult L and Wu AW (2005) Clinical practice guidelines and quality of care for older patients with multiple comorbid diseases: Implications for pay for performance. JAMA 294: 716-724.
Butler R (1969) Age-ism: Another form of bigotry. The Gerontologist, 9, 243-246.
Dickenson-Hazard N (2004) Global health issues and challenges. Journal of Nursing Scholarship 36: 6-10.
Butler R (1080). Ageism: A Forward. Journal of Social Issues 36: 8-11.
Dodgson JE and Struthers R (2005) Indigenous women's voices: marginalization and health. Journal of Transcultural Nursing 16: 339-346.
Durie M H (2001) Cultural competence and medical practice in New Zealand. Paper presented at Australian and New Zealand Boards and Council Conference, 22 November. Wellington, NZ.
Eliopoulos C (2005) Gerontological Nursing 6th edn, Lippincott, New York.
Eraker SA, Kirscht JP and Becker MH (1984) Understanding and improving patient compliance. Annals of Internal Medicine 100: 258-268.
Evans R and Stoddard G (2003) Consuming research, producing policy? American Journal of Public Health 93: 371-379.
Florin J, Ehrenberg A and Ehnfors M (2006) Patient participation in clinical decision-making in nursing: a comparative study of nurses' and patients' perceptions. Journal of Clinical Nursing 15: 1498-1508.
Giddings LS (2005) A theoretical model of social consciousness. Advances in Nursing Science 28: 224-239.
Gray R, Wykes T and Gournay K (2002) From compliance to concordance: a review of literature on interventions to enhance compliance with antipsychotic medication. Journal of Psychiatric & Mental Health Nursing 9: 277-284.
Hall LE (1969) The Loeb Centre for Nursing and Rehabilitation, Montefiore Hospital and Medical Centre, Bronx, New York. International Journal of Nursing Studies 6: 81-97.
Horsfall J (2003) Consumers/service users: is nursing listening? Issues in Mental Health Nursing 24: 381-396.
Jenkinson C, Coulter A, Bruster S, Richards N and Chandola T (2002) Patients' experiences and satisfaction with health care: results of a questionnaire study of specific aspects of care. Quality and Safety in Health Care 11: 335-339.
Jones C (2001) Levels of racism: A theoretic framework and a gardener's tale. American Journal of Public Health, 90: 1212-1215.
Julia M and Kondrat ME (2005) Health care in the social development context: indigenous, participatory and empowering approaches International Social Work 48: 537-552.
Masotti P, Fick, R, Johnson-Masotti A and MacLeod S (2006) Healthy naturally occurring retirement communities: A low-cost approach to facilitating healthy aging. Community Matters in Healthy Aging 96: 1164-1170.
Maze CDM (2005) Registered Nurses' personal rights vs professional responsibility in caring for members of underserved and disenfranchised populations. Journal of Clinical Nursing 14: 546-554.
McCormack B (2004) Person-centredness in gerontological nursing: An overview International Journal of Older People Nursing in association with Journal of Clinical Nursing 13, 31-38.
Meleis AI and Im E-O (1999) Transcending marginalization in knowledge development. Nursing Inquiry, 6: 94-102.
Neville SJ (2005) Delirium In The Older Adult: A Critical Gerontological Approach. PhD thesis, Massey University, New Zealand.
Neville SJ (2006) Delirium and older people: repositioning care. International Journal of Older People Nursing 1: 113-120.
Peplau H (1952). Interpersonal relations in nursing. Putnam's Sons, Philadelphia.
Sporle A (2003) ‘So Māori fits in how?' - the realities of attempting to implement kaupapa Māori practice evaluation in a contractual situation. In Evaluating Policy And Practice: A New Zealand Reader (Lunt N, Davidson C and McKegg K) (Eds), Pearson Education New Zealand, Auckland NZ, pp. 64-67.
Suhonen R, Valiamaki M and Leiho-Kilipi H (2005) Individualized care, quality of life and satisfaction with nursing care. Journal of Advanced Nursing 50: 283-292.
Tagliareni E, Waters V and Anderson M (2003) The aging experience. In Anderson M (ed.) Caring For Older Adults Holistically 3rd edn pp. 2-15, F. A. Davis, Philadelphia,.
Tomlinson M and Gibson GJ (2006) Obstructive sleep apnoea syndrome: a nurse-led domiciliary service. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 55: 391-397.
Vassa EB (2005) Examining the margins: a concept analysis of marginalization. Advances in Nursing Science 28: 194-202.
Waters KR and Easton N (1999) Individualized care: is it possible to plan and carry out? Journal of Advanced Nursing 29: 79-87.
Watson J (1985) Nursing: Human Science and Human Care: A Theory Of Nursing. Appleton Century Crofts, New York.
West E, Barron DN and Reeves C (2005) Overcoming the barriers to patient-centred care: time, tools and training. Journal of Clinical Nursing 14: 435-443.
Whetten K, Leserman J, Whetten R, Ostermann J, Thielman N, Swartz M and Stangi D (2006) Exploring lack of trust in care providers and the government as a barrier to health service use. American Journal of Public Health 96: 716-721.
Wilson D (2003) The nurse's role in improving indigenous health status. Contemporary Nurse, 15: 232-240.
Wilson DL (2004) Nga Kairaranga Oranga - The Weavers of Health And Wellbeing: A Grounded Theory. PhD thesis, Massey University, New Zealand.
Wilson D and Roberts M (2005) Māori health initiatives In Wepa D (ed.) Cultural Safety In Aotearoa New Zealand, pp. 157-169, Pearson Prentice Hall, Auckland NZ.
Wilson PM, Kendall S and Brooks F (2006) Nurses' responses to expert patients: the rhetoric and reality of self-management in long-term conditions: a grounded theory study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 43: 803-818.
eContent Home