Archives
An Evaluation of the Seminal Work of Patricia Benner: Theory or philosophy?
Tanya K Altmann
Assistant Professor of Nursing, Division of Nursing, Sacramento State University, Sacramento CA, United States of America
Abstract
The purpose of this article is to review the seminal work of Patricia Benner, From Novice to Expert, in order to assert it as a philosophy and not a theory. In the literature there is no clear consensus on where this model stands - theory or philosophy. There is no intent to devalue Patricia Benner's work as it is valuable and has become widely used in nursing practice, research, education and administration. However, as a philosophy, Benner's interpretive work is more constructive.
Appropriate use of this model requires an understanding of whether it is a theory or a philosophy, its underpinnings and an assessment of its development and testing. This can be accomplished by knowing the differences between a theory and a philosophy and by reviewing the ways of knowing and processes of reasoning which are necessary for skill acquisition. Much of the critique of Benner's work falls into two categories: it is not quantitative research and there are issues with the use of narratives. These will be reviewed. Judgment and understanding of the nature of Benner's model allows for its appropriate use in journal articles, research, or other projects and/or modification as necessary.
Keywords
nursing philosophy, Patricia Brenner, novice to expert, skill acquisition, theory
References
Allen D and Cloyes K (2005) The language of 'experience' in nursing research, Nursing Inquiry 12: 98-105.
Benner P (1984) From Novice to Expert: Excellence and Power in Clinical Nursing Practice. Menlo Park, CA, Addison-Wesley.
Benner PA, Tanner CA and Chesla CA (1996) Expertise in Nursing Practice: Caring, Clinical Judgment and Ethics. New York: Springer.
Brykczynski KA (2002) Patricia Benner: From novice to expert: Excellence and power in clinical nursing practice. In Marriner-Tomey A and Alligood MR (eds) Nursing Theorists and Their Work 5th edn, pp.165-180. St Louis, MO, Mosby.
Carper BA (1978) Fundamental patterns of knowing in nursing, Advances in Nursing Science 1: 13-23.
Carper BA (1997) Response to ‘Perspectives on Knowing: A model of nursing knowledge'. In Nicoll LH (ed) Perspectives on Nursing Theory 3rd edn, pp.331-333. Philadelphia, Lippincott-Raven.
Cash K (1995) Benner and expertise in nursing: A critique, International Journal of Nursing Studies 32: 527-34.
Chitty KK (2005) Professional Nursing: Concepts & Challenges 4th edn, pp.278. St Louis, MO, Elsevier Saunders
Creswell JW (1998) Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design. Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage.
Darbyshire P (1994) Skilled expert practice: Is it ‘all in the mind'? A response to English's critique of Benner's novice to expert model, Journal of Advanced Nursing 19: 755-61.
Dickoff J and James P (1997) Taking concepts as guides to action: Exploring kinds of know-how. In Nicoll LH (ed) Perspectives on Nursing Theory 3rd edn, pp.645-659. Philadelphia, Lippincott-Raven.
Effken JA (2001) Informational basis for expert intuition, Journal of Advanced Nursing 34: 246-255.
English I (1993) Intuition as a function of the expert nurse: A critique of Benner's novice to expert model, Journal of Advanced Nursing 18: 387-393.
Kuhn TS (1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Marriner-Tomey A (ed) (1994) Nursing Theorists and Their Work 3rd edn, St Louis, Mo: Mosby-Year Book.
Marriner-Tomey A and Alligood MR (Eds) (2002) Nursing Theorists and Their Work 5th edn, St Louis, Mo: Mosby.
McKee K, Abel K and Bonafini-Nordin F (nd) Patricia Benner's Nursing Theories, accessed at http://www.eden.rutgers.edu/~kmckee/utilization.html on 5 April 2004.
Meleis AI (1991) Theoretical Nursing: Development and Progress 2nd edn, Philadelphia, Lippincott.
Myrick F and Barrett C (1992) Preceptor selection criteria in Canadian baccalaureate schools of nursing - A survey, The Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 24: 53-68.
Nelson S (2004) The search for the good in nursing? The burden of ethical expertise, Nursing Philosophy 5: 12-22.
Nelson S and McGillion M (2004) Expertise or performance? Questioning the rhetoric of contemporary narrative use in nursing, Journal of Advanced Nursing 47: 631-638.
Nubiola J (2000) Charles S Peirce, accessed at http://www.unav.es/users/Nupedia_Charles_S.html on 20 October 2006.
Padgett SM (2000) Benner and the critics: Promoting scholarly dialogue... including commentary by Thompson JL, Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice 14: 249-271.
Polanyi M (1958) Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post Critical Philosophy. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Purkis ME (1994) Entering the field: Intrusions of the social and its exclusion from studies of nursing practice, International Journal of Nursing Studies 31: 315-336.
Rudge T (1992) Reflections on Benner: A critical Perspective, Contemporary Nurse 1: 84-88.
Schunk DH (1996) Learning Theories 2nd edn, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice-Hall.
Shapiro MM (1998) Review of the literature. A career ladder based on Benner's model: An analysis of expected outcomes, Journal of Nursing Administration 28(3): 13-19.
Thompson JL (1990) Hermeneutic inquiry. In Moody E (ed) Advancing Nursing Science through Research (2: 223-280).
Walker OL and Avant KC (1995) Strategies for Theory Construction in Nursing 3rd edn, Norwalk, CT, Appleton & Lange.
eContent Home