Archives
Contextualizing Nurse Education in Israel
Sociodemography, labor market dynamics and professional training
Daphna Birenbaum-Carmeli
Abstract
Background
Motivations for selecting nursing as a career are usually explored through direct questions to candidates and students.
Purpose
The present article aims to uncover ties between the demand structure for the profession and broader socio-demographic and economic processes.
Method
Data covering a ten year period was retrieved from an Israeli university. It is suggested that the intensity of demographic and economic shifts in Israel allows clearer observation of more general student-related processes that probably take place, if on a smaller scale, virtually everywhere.
Findings and Discussion
Many of the new recruits to academic nursing programs in Israel in 1996-2004 came from two somewhat marginal sub-populations: immigrants from the Former Soviet Union and Israeli Palestinians. The high, yet decreasing percentage of the former category and the rise in the latter are interpreted in terms of competing forces in the local healthcare labor market, immigrants' adaptation and economic fluctuations.
Conclusion
The demand for nursing studies corresponds to socio-demographic and economic changes. It may be beneficial to consider such links in long term planning and training policies.
Keywords
nurse education, labour market, immigration, Israel
References
Adva Center (2003) Gaps in employment by ethnicity and gender, accessed at www.adva.org/ivrit/homepage_heb.html.
Al-Haj M (1991) Education and Social Change among Arabs in Israel. International Center for Peace in the Middle East, Tel Aviv.
Al-Haj M (1995) Education, Empowerment and Control: The Case of the Arabs in Israel, pp. 204-206. New York, State University of New York Press
Beck CT (2000) The experience of choosing nursing as a career, Journal of Nursing Education 39: 320-322.
Beenstock M, Ben-Menachem Y (1997) The labor market experience of CIS immigrants to Israel: 1989-1994, International Migration 35: 187-224.
Central Bureau of Statistics (1997) Internal Migration in Israel of Immigrants of the 1990's, table 1, Publication no 1109.
Central Bureau of Statistics (1998) Applicants, students and university graduates, 1994-1996: Demographic and geographic characteristics, Publication no 1068: 66.
Central Bureau of Statistics (1999) Education and Culture, Israel Statistics Annual 50, table 22.34: 22-53.
Central Bureau of Statistics (1999) Education and Culture, Israel Statistics Annual 50, table 22-29: 22-46.
Central Bureau of Statistics (2003) table 18 pp.68-69.
Central Bureau of Statistics (2005) table 2.7.
Central Bureau of Statistics (2005) table 2.8, p.46.
Central Bureau of Statistics, Monthly report (2006/3) Table c/2.
Doron A, Kargar H (1993) The politics of immigration policy in Israel, International Migration 31: 497-512.
Eisikovits R (1997) The educational experience and performance of immigrants and minority students in Israel, Anthropology and Education Quarterly 28(3): 394-410.
Guri-Rosenblit S (1996) Trends in access to Israeli higher education 1981-96: From a privilege to a right, European Journal of Education 31: 321-340.
Guri-Rosenblit S (1999) Changing boundaries in Israeli higher education, Mediterranean Journal of Educational Studies 42: 91-114.
Hercowitz Z and Yashiv E (1997) The effects of mass immigration on the employment of natives, Discussion paper no. 5-97, Pinhas Sapir Center for Development, Tel Aviv, Tel Aviv University.
Kelly N, Shoemanker M and Steele T (1996) The experience of being a male student nurse, Journal of Nursing Education 35: 170-174.
Kersten J, Bakewell K and Meyer D (1990) Motivating factors in students' choice of nursing as a career, Journal of Nursing Education 30: 30-33.
Kraus V and Hartman M (1994) Changes in occupational prestige in Israel 1974-1989, Megamot 36(2): 78-87 [Hebrew].
Menachem G and Spiro SE (1999) Immigrants in a restructuring economy: A partial test of theories, International Migration 37: 569-585.
Mesch G and Stier H (1997) Spatial mismatch, stratification and community unemployment: The Israeli case: Pinhas Sapir Center for Development, Discussion paper no 1-97, Tel Aviv University Adva Center (2004) Income by Ethnic group accessed at www.adva.org/ivrit/homepage_heb.html.
Ministry of Health (2004) Human Resources in the Health Professions, accessed at: www.health.gov.il/Download/pages/nurse2005a.doc;
www.health.gov.il/Download/pages/nurse2005c.doc;
www.health.gov.il/Download/pages/2004_chap2.doc.
Raijman R and Semyonov M (1998) Best of times, worst of times, and occupational mobility: The case of Soviet immigrants in Israel, International Migration 36: 287- 311s.
Shuval JT (1992) Social Dimensions of Health: the Israeli experience. Westport CT, Praeger.
Smooha S (1989) Arabs and Jews in Israel: Conflicting and Shared Attitudes in a Divided Society, vol 1. Boulder CO, Westview.
Swirski S and Konor-Atias E (2006) Employees, employers and the national income pie: 2005 Report, Tel Aviv, Adva Center.
While A and Blackman C (1998) Reflections on nursing as a career choice, Journal of Nursing Management 6: 231-237.
Williams B, Wertenberger DH and Gushuliak T (1997) Why students choose nursing, Journal of Nursing Education 36: 346-348.
eContent Home