Archives
How Social Myths About Childhood, Motherhood and Medicine Affect the Detection of Subtle Developmental Problems in Young Children
Jane Williams
Project Officer, School of Nursing Sciences, James Cook University, Townsville QLD
Abstract
Focus by child health professionals on the well-being of young Australian children and their families has intensified in the past decade, with particular attention drawn to the importance of the early detection and intervention of developmental problems. While many children with developmental difficulties are detected in the preschool years, those with more subtle forms of developmental problems are often only noticed by their mothers, passing unnoticed by professionals until the children begin school and fail socially or academically. This study aimed to ascertain ways in which child health professionals may utilise the experience of mothers to improve early recognition and diagnosis of subtle developmental and behavioural problems in children.
French philosopher, Roland Barthes (1973) proposed that myths play an important social role in defining underlying social values that affect how people interpret what others say or do. This paper explores how the social myths of childhood, motherhood and medicine impact upon the early detection of children with subtle developmental problems. In particular, it examines how social myths affect when and how mothers become concerned about their children's development, from whom they seek advice, and the responses which mothers receive in regard to their concerns.
Mythical notions of the 'blameless child', 'boys will be boys' and 'children who look OK are OK', and the constituted myth of motherhood, are all shown to affect when mothers become concerned about their children's development. What mothers do about their concerns and the responses they receive from child health professionals are also influenced by these myths. The myth of medicine is also examined to determine how it affects communication between mothers and doctors, the roles and responsibilities of doctors, and the value placed on a mother's concerns by doctors.
Keywords
early childhood development, subtle developmental problems, early detection, child health, mothers, myths
References
Badinter E (1981) The myth of motherhood: an historical view of the maternal instinct. London: Souvenir Press.
Bank L, Forgatch MS, Patterson GR and Fetrow RA (1993) Parenting practices of single mothers: mediators of negative contextual factors, Journal of Marriage and the Family 55(2): 371-384.
Barthes R (1973) Mythologies. London: Paladin Grafton Books. (Original work published 1957).
Baumrind D and Black AE (1967) Socialization practices associated with dimensions of competence in preschool boys and girls, Child Development 38(2): 291-327.
Becker PT (1987) Sensitivity to infant development and behavior: a comparison of adolescent and adult single mothers, Research in Nursing & Health 10(3): 119-127.
Bricker D, Squires J and Mounts L (1995) Ages & Stages Questionnaires: a parent-completed, child-monitoring system. Baltimore: Paul H Brookes Publishing Co.
Carlo G, Raffaelli M, Laible DJ and Meyer KA (1999) Why are girls less physically aggressive than boys? Personality and parenting mediators of physical aggression, Sex Roles 40(9-10): 711-729.
Carpenter LR (1999) 'The effect of a child's attention deficit hyperactivity disorder on a mother: the hidden disability of motherhood'. Unpublished PhD, Griffith University, Brisbane.
Collins WA, Maccoby EE, Steinberg L, Hetherington AM and Bornstein MH (2000) Contemporary research on parenting, American Psychologist 55(2): 218-232.
Curtis J (2002) Does your child have a hidden disability? London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Eliade M (2003) 'Myth in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, Retrieved 24 Nov 2003 from http://etext.lib.virginia.edu/cgi-local/DHI/dhi.cgi?id=dv3-40.
Eliot A (1976) Myths. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Frankenburg WK (2002) Developmental surveillance and screening of infants and young children, Pediatrics 109(1): 144-145.
Friedman MM (1992) Family development theory. In Friedman MM (ed) Family Nursing: Theory and Practice, Norwalk, CT: Appletone and Lange.
Garey A and Arendell T (1999) Children, work and family: some thoughts on ‘mother blame'. Retrieved 20 July 2005 from http://www.bc.edu/bc_org/avp/wfnetwork/berkeley/papers/4.pdf
Glascoe FP (1999) Using parent's concerns to detect and address developmental and behavioural problems. Journal of the Society of Pediatric Nurses 4(1): 24 - 39.
Glascoe FP (2000) Detecting and addressing developmental and behavioural problems in primary care, Pediatric Nursing 26(3): 251 - 266.
Glascoe FP (2001) Are overreferrals on developmental screening tests really a problem? Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine 155(1): 54-65.
Glascoe FP (2003) Parents' evaluation of developmental status: how well do parents' concerns identify children with behavioral and emotional problems? Clinical Pediatrics 42(2): 133-139.
Glascoe FP (2005) Commonly used screening tools. Retrieved 10 July 2006 from http://www.dbpeds.org/articles/detail.cfm?textid=539
Hanna BA (1996) 'The intersection of autonomy and social control: negotiating teenage motherhood'. Unpublished PhD, Deakin University, Geelong.
Jellinek MS, Murphy JM, Robinson J, Feins A, Lamb S and Fenton T (1988) Pediatric Symptom Checklist: Screening school-age children for psychosocial dysfunction, Journal of Pediatrics 112(2): 201-208.
Johnstone DD and Swanson DH (2003) Invisible mothers: a content analysis of motherhood ideologies and myths in magazines, Sex Roles 49(1/2): 21-33.
Jung CG and Kerenyi K (1973) Essays on a science of mythology: the myth of the divine child and the mysteries of Eleusis. New York: Bolligen Foundation (Original work published 1949).
Kaplan EA (1992) Motherhood and representation. London: Routledge.
Kennedy D (2000) The roots of child study: philosophy, history and religion, Teachers College Record 102(3): 514-538.
Lavers A (1982) Roland Barthes: Structuralism and after. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.
Levi-Strauss C (1966) The savage mind. London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson (Original work published 1962).
Lupton D (1994) Medicine as culture: illness, disease and the body in Western societies. London: Sage.
Maccoby EE and Jacklin CN (1980) Sex differences in aggression: a rejoinder and reprise, Child Development 51(4): 964-980.
Malacrida C (2003) Cold comfort: mothers, professionals, and Attention Deficit Disorder. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.
Malinowski B (1954) Myth in primitive psychology. In Magic, science and religion and other essays 1926, New York: Double Day pp 72-124.
Marteau TM and Johnstone M (1990) Health professionals: a source of variance in health outcomes, Psychology and Health 5: 47-58.
Parker R (1995) Torn in two: the experience of maternal ambivalence. London: Virago Press.
Regalado M and Halfon N (2001) Primary care services promoting optimal child development from birth to 3 years: review of literature, Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine 155(12): 1311-1323.
Rogers C (1959) A theory of therapy, personality and interpersonal relationships as developed in the client centred framework. In Koch S (ed) Psychology: a study of a science Vol 3, New York: McGraw-Hill.
Rogers D (2005) 'Mothering and Attention Deficit Disorder: the impact of professional power.' Unpublished PhD, James Cook University, Townsville
Samuel R and Thompson P (1990) The myths we live by. London: Routledge.
Sanders MR (1999) Triple P-positive parenting program: towards an empirically validated multilevel parenting and family support strategy for the prevention of behavior and emotional problems in children, Clinicial Child and Family Psychology Review 2(2): 71-90.
Sanders MR, Markie-Dadds C, Tully LA and Bor W (2000) The triple P-positive parenting program: a comparison of enhanced standard, and self-directed behavioral family intervention for parents of children with early onset conduct problems, Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 68(4): 624-640.
Sarbin TR and Mancuso JC (1995) Some unarticulated premises in the rhetorical construction of DSM categories. Retrieved 12 October 2005 from http://ksi.cpsc.ucalgary.ca/PCP/1995Q3/0104.html.
Siever LJ and Davis KL (1991) A psychobiological perspective on personality disorders, The American Journal of Psychiatry 148(12): 1647-1658.
Singh I (2004) Doing their jobs: mothering with Ritalin in a culture of mother-blame, Social Science & Medicine 59(6): 1193-1205.
Squires J, Bricker D and Twombly E (2002) Ages & Stages Questionnaires: Social-Emotional. Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co.
Stone SD (1995) The myth of bodily perfection, Disability & Society 10(4): 413-424.
Swigart J (1991) The myth of the bad mother: parenting without guilt. New York: Avon Books.
Thorne S (1993) Health belief systems in perspective, Journal of Advanced Nursing 18(12): 1931-1941.
Thurer SL (1994) The myths of motherhood. New York: Houghton Mifflin Co.
Tieger T (1980) On the biological basis of sex differences in aggression, Child Development 51(2): 943-963.
Todd S and Jones S (2003) 'Mum's the word!' Maternal accounts of dealings with the professional world, Journal of Applied Research in Intellectual Disabilities 16: 229-244.
Trubshaw RN (2003) Explore mythology. Loughborough, UK: Heart of Albion Press.
van Dijk TA (1998) Ideology: a multidisciplinary approach. London: Sage.
Williams J (2005) 'Learning from mothers: how myths, policies and practices affect the detection of subtle developmental problems in children' Unpublished PhD, James Cook University, Townsville
Williams J (2006) Learning from mothers: how myths, policies and practices affect the detection of subtle developmental problems in children, Child: Care, Health and Development (in press).
Williams J and Holmes CA (2004) Improving the detection of children with subtle developmental problems, Journal of Child Health Care 8(1): 34-46.
Williams J and Holmes CA (2005) Literary folkloristics: using literary theories to read life stories, Qualitative Research Journal 5(2): 151-167.
Wright L and Leahey M (1999) Maximizing time, minimizing suffering: the 15 minute (or less) family interview, Journal of Family Nursing 5(3): 259-274.
eContent Home