Collaborative Voices: Ongoing reflections on nursing competencies
In a rapidly changing Australian health care environment, providers of undergraduate nursing programs are continually upgrading their assessment methods to ensure that graduates are competent and safe to practice. Competence assessment is based on the existing Australian Nursing and Midwifery Council (ANMC) Competency Standards for Registered Nurses. It is acknowledged that there are issues surrounding the validity and reliability of current assessment methods, primarily due to organisational constraints both at the University and the service provider level. There are a number of highly reliable tools available that enable assessment of nursing students in the psychomotor domain. Assessment in other domains is less precise.
This paper explores some of the issues relating to competence assessment processes in order to promote discussion and discourse between educators, facilities and policy makers. It is envisaged that increased debate will result in an enhanced level of academic and clinical preparation for the upcoming nursing workforce in this country.
Centre for Community Science, Population & Social Health Program, Griffith Health Institute, Griffith University (Logan), Meadowbrook QLD
Program Manager/Lecturer, Competence Assessment Service, School of Nursing and Health Studies, Central Queensland University, Rockhampton QLD
Director, Research and Policy Program, Queensland Nursing Council, Brisbane QLD
Professor Mental Health, Registered Nurse, Director, Centre for Rural & Remote Area Health, University of Southern Queensland, Toowoomba, QLD
Head, School of Nursing and Health Studies, Central Queensland University, Rockhampton QLD
Senior Lecturer, School of Nursing Sciences, James Cook University, Townsville QLD
Alfaro-Lefevre R (2004) Critical Thinking and Clinical Judgment 3rd edn. St Louis: Saunders.
Australian Nursing Council (ANC) (2002) Code of Ethics for Nurses in Australia. Australian Nursing and Midwifery Council, Canberra.
Australian Nursing Council (ANC) (2000) National Competency Standards for Registered Nurses. Australian Nursing and Midwifery Council, Canberra.
Barnett R (1994) The Limits of Competence: Knowledge, Higher Education and Society, Society for Research into Higher Education, Buckingham, UK, Open University Press.
Barnett R (1997) Higher education: A critical business, Society for Research into Higher Education, Buckingham, UK Open University Press.
Benor D and Leviyof I (1997) The development of students' perceptions of effective teaching: the ideal, biggest and poorest clinical teacher in nursing, Journal of Nursing Education 36(5): 206-11.
Birkholz G, Clements P, Cox R and Gaume A (2004). Educational innovations: Students' self-identified learning needs: a case study of baccalaureate students designing their own death and dying course curriculum, Journal of Nursing Education 43(1): 36-9.
Carr D (1993) Questions of competence, British Journal of Educational Studies 41(3): 253-271.
Chapman H (1999) Some important limitations of competency-based education with respect to nurse education: an Australian perspective, Nurse Education Today 19(2): 129-35.
Clark R, Dunn S and Walker N (1996) Implementation of nursing competencies: profiling best assessment practice, Australian Critical Care 9(4): 151.
Duffy K (2004) Failing students. Report commissioned by the Nursing and Midwifery Council UK, available online at: http://www.nmc-uk.org/nmc/main/publications/mentor_study.pdf
Filer D (2001) Faculty perceptions of competencies in the nursing profession. Doctoral Dissertation, University of North Dakota, ND.
Fitzpatrick J, While A and Roberts J (1997) Measuring clinical nurse performance: development of the King's Nurse Performance Scale, International Journal of Nursing Studies 34(3): 222-30.
Freese B (1989) Application of a formative transactional evaluation model with the South Carolina professional nursing competencies. Doctoral Dissertation, University of Georgia, GA.
Frisch N, George V, Govoni A, Jennings-Sanders A and McCahon C (2003) Teaching nurses to focus on the health needs of populations: a Master's Degree Program in population health nursing, Nurse Educator 28(5): 212-6.
Gerber R and Velde C (1997) A competence model for professional practice in the clerical-administrative occupations, Journal of Vocational Education and Training 49(3): 455-476.
Gibson F, Fletcher M and Casey A (2003) Classifying general and specialist children's nursing competencies, Journal of Advanced Nursing 44(6): 591-602.
Grant J (1999) The incapacitating effects of competence: A critique, Advances in Health Science Education 4(3): 271-277
Hager P and Becket D (1995) Philosophical underpinnings of the integrated conception of competence, Educational Philosophy and Theory 27(1): 1-24.
Jones A (1999) The place of judgement in competency-based assessment, Journal of Vocational Education and Training 51(1): 145-160.
Kermode S and Brown C (1995) Where have all the flowers gone? Nursing's escape from the radical critique, Contemporary Nurse 4(1): 8-15.
Lew S, Page G, Schuwirth L Baron-Maldonado M, Lescop J, Paget N, Southgate L and Wade W (2002) Procedures for establishing defensible programmes for assessing practice performance, Papers from the 10th Cambridge Conference, Medical Education 36: 936-941
Lum G (2004) On the non-discursive nature of competence, Educational Philosophy and Theory 36(5):485-496.
Malko K (1988) Evaluation for accountability, Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 5(4): 12-8.
McAvoy P, McCrorie P, Jolly B, Ayers A, Cox J, Howes, A, Macdonald E, Slimmon D and Southgate L (2001) Training the assessors for the General Medical Council's Performance Procedures, Medical Education 35(S1): 29-35
McGrath P (2001) New Horizons in Spirituality Research. In Rumpbold B (ed) Spirituality and Palliative Care, Melbourne, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
McGrath P (1999) Exploring Spirituality Through Research: An Important but Challenging Task, Progress in Palliative Care 7(1): 3-9.
Menges R (1975) Assessing readiness for professional practice, Review of Educational Research 45(2): 173-207.
Moxham L and Reid-Searl K (2005) Effective clinical teaching: a contemporary approach to training the trainer. In Crebert G, Davies L and Phillips S (eds) Proceedings of the effective teaching and learning conference 2004, 4-5 November. Brisbane.
Norman I, Watson R, Murrells T, Calman L and Redfern S (2002) The validity and reliability of methods to assess the competence to practise of pre-registration nursing and midwifery students, International Journal of Nursing Studies 39(2): 133-45.
Ohrling K and Hallberg I (2001) The meaning of preceptorship: nurses' lived experience of being a preceptor, Journal of Advanced Nursing 33(4): 530-540.
Pohlman K (2001) Legal framework and financial accountability for school nursing practice. In Schmidt N and Gelfman M (eds) Legal Issues in School Nursing North Branch, MN, Sunrise River Press
Poster E and Marcontel M (1999) Nursing practice management. School nursing role and competence, Journal of School Nursing 15(2): 34-6; 38-42.
Roberts-Davis M. and Read S (2001) Clinical role clarification: using the Delphi method to establish similarities and differences between Nurse Practitioners and Clinical Nurse Specialists, Journal of Clinical Nursing 10(1): 33-43.
Rudge T and Gerschwitz M (1995) Validation of cues for competencies of beginning level mental health nurses: an exploratory study in South Australian mental health agencies, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Mental Health Nursing 4(1): 31-41.
Sangpoisit K (2000) A balance between well care nursing and ill care nursing in the 4-year baccalaureate nursing programs of the Thai public sector. Doctor Dissertation - Research, University of Pennsylvania, PA.
Smith S (2003) Developing and utilizing end of live nursing competencies, Home Health Care Management and Practice 15(2): 116-22.
Tollefson J (2004) Clinical Psychomotor Skills: Assessment Tools for Student Nurses 2nd edn. Tuggerah, NSW: Social Sciences Press.
Tsuzuki C (2004) Identifying the need to support with client: nursing competencies of expert public health nurses in routine health examinations for children, Journal of Japan Academy of Nursing Science 24(2): 3-12.
Tzeng H (2004) Nurses' self-assessment of their nursing competencies, job demands and job performance in the Taiwan hospital system, International Journal of Nursing Studies 41(5): 487-96.
Tzeng H (2003) Demand and supply for nursing competencies in Taiwan's hospital industry, Nursing Economics 21(3): 130-9.
Utley-Smith Q (2004) Five Competencies needed by new baccalaureate graduates, Nursing Education Perspectives 25(4): 166-70.
Villaire M (1996) The Synergy model of certified practice - creating safe passage for patients, Critical Care Nurse 16(40): 95-99.
Wandelt M and Stewart D (1975) Slater Nursing Competencies Rating Scale. New York, Appleton-Century Crofts.
Wendt A (2001) End-of-life competencies and the NCLEX-RN examination, Nursing Outlook 49(3): 138-41.
Wheelahan L (2004) What are the alternatives to training packages? Paper presented at the Australian VET Research Association Conference, March 2004, Canberra.
Zhang Z, Luk W, Arthur D and Wong T (2001) Nursing competencies: personal characteristics contributing to effective nursing performance. Journal of Advanced Nursing 33(4): 467-74.
Zerwekh J (1990) A qualitative description of the competencies of expert public health nurses. Doctoral Dissertation, Seattle University, WA.
nursing, competence, curriculum, clinical assessment, education, reliability and validity