Archives
Violence, Zero Tolerance and the Subversion of Professional Practice
Colin Holmes
Adjunct Professor of Nursing, School of Nursing Sciences, James Cook University, Townsville QLD
Abstract
Assaults on health care staff have been a fact of life since the earliest years of organised health services, but it is only in recent years that governments have begun to acknowledge the problem. Assaults not only inflict physical and emotional injury, but undermine morale, create a climate of fear, and subvert the quality of care. They are also costly in terms of lost labour, compensation, and legal and procedural expenses.
The response to violence in health care settings has thus far ranged from what might be called the 'Ostrich position', in which it is simply ignored, to training in self-defence, the deployment of security staff in clinical areas, conflict resolution training and, more recently, the policy of 'zero tolerance'.
This paper examines the rationale for zero tolerance policies, drawing on their origins and applications in the United States and Britain. It suggests that zero tolerance is an ineffective response to violence in health care settings, and its adoption by authorities in Australia should be rejected. It is further argued, that resource allocation and marginalisation are identifiable and modifiable factors contributing to violence in our health care systems.
Keywords
ethics, professionalism, violence, zero tolerance
References
American Bar Association (2004) Zero Tolerance
Policy: Report. American Bar Association. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.abanet.org/crimjust/juvjus/zerotolreport.html
ABC Online (2005) Mental health nurses reject zero tolerance
policy. ABC Online 5 April 2005. Accessed 5 Apr 2005
http://www.abc.net.au/
Abood RR (1996) Errors in pharmacy practice. US Pharmacist 21(3): 122-132.
Anderson T (2005) Patients face discharge from hospital in
total smoking ban. The Independent 22 May. Accessed 25 May 2005
http://news.independent.co.uk/uk/health_medical/story.jsp?story=640425
Australian Nursing Federation (2004) Zero tolerance for inaction. Australian Nursing Journal 12(5): 7.
Beech B (2001) Zero tolerance of violence against healthcare staff. Nursing Standard 15(16): 39-41.
Bell MC, Campbell JC and Cycyota CS (2002) Assessment and prevention of sexual harassment of employees: an applied guide to creating healthy organizations. International Journal of Selection and Assessment 10(1/2): 160-167.
Bennett R (2004) The human cost of zero tolerance. The Guardian 11 Oct 2004.
Berlet C and Lyons MN (2000) Right-Wing Populism in America, Too Close for Comfort. New York, Guilford Press.
Bonomo Y and Bowes G (2001) Annotation: Putting harm reduction into an adolescent context. Journal of Paediatric Child Health 37: 5-8.
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) News (2003) Violent
patients in surgery ban. BBC News Online 29 May 2003. Accessed
http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/pr/fr/-/1/hi/england/west_midlands/2947242.stm.
Brockmann M (2002) New perspectives on violence in social care. Journal of Social Work 1(2): 29-44.
Campus Report (1995) A pox on mouthwash. Campus Report 10 Apr 1995: 2.
Casella R (2003) Zero tolerance policy in schools: rationale, consequences and alternatives. Teachers' College Record 105(5): 872-892.
Cassidy S (2005) Union calls for the expulsion of violent
and disruptive pupils to halt class abuse. The Independent 30 Mar. Accessed 1 June 2005
http://education.independent.co.uk/news
Childs ND (1998) Schools rethinking 'zero tolerance' policies. Family Practice News 28(18): 45.
Cole A (2003) Violence against staff: Government health warning. The Health Service Journal 113(5871): 24-25.
Coleman R (2003) Images from a neo-liberal city: the state, surveillance and social control. Critical Criminology 12: 21-42.
Coleman R and Sim J (2000) 'You'll never walk alone', CCTV surveillance, order and neo-liberal rule in Liverpool city. British Journal of Sociology 51(4): 623-639.
Commission for Health Improvement (2004) NHS Staff
Survey 2003. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.healthcarecommission.org.uk/assetRoot/04/00/77/47/04007747.pdf
Comptroller and Auditor General (2003) A Safer Place
to Work: Protecting NHS Hospital and Ambulance Staff from Violence and Aggression.
Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General HC 527 Session 2002-2003, 27
Mar 2003. London, The Stationery Office. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.nao.org.uk/publications/nao_reports/02-03/0203527.pdf
Cooper CL and Swanson N (2002) Workplace Violence in the Health Sector: State of the Art. Geneva, International Labour Organization, and World Health Organization. Accessed 22 Aug 2005 https://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/injury/en/WVstateart.pdf
Cunneen C (1999a) Zero tolerance policing: implications
for indigenous people. Paper prepared for the Law and Justice Section of
the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Island Commission, Jan 1999. Woden, ACT,
The Commission. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.atsic.gov.au/issues/law_and_justice/
zero_tolerance_policing/Report/default.asp
Cunneen C (1999b) Zero tolerance policing and the experience of New York City. Current Issues in Criminal Justice 10(3): 299-313.
Dawson J, West M and Beinart S (2005) NHS National Staff
Survey 2004: Summary of Key Findings. London, Commission for Healthcare
Audit and Inspection. Accessed 22 Aug 2005
http://www.healthcarecommission.org.uk
Dennis N (ed) (1998) Zero Tolerance Policing in a Free Society. Revised and enlarged 2nd edn. London, Institute of Economic Affairs, Health and Welfare Unit.
Department of Health (1999) Survey of Reported
Sickness Absence, Accidents and Violence in NHS Trusts. Press Release. London,
Department of Health. Accessed 1 Jun 2005
http://www.dh.gov.uk/
Department of Health (2001) Violent patients can now
be denied treatment. Press release. London, Department of Health. Accessed 1
Jun 2005
http://www.dh.gov.uk/
Department of Health (2002a) National Minimum
Standards for General Adult Services in Psychiatric Intensive Care Units
(PICUs) and Low Secure Environments. Report (eds) Dr Stephen Pereira and Colum
Clinton on behalf of the PICU/Low Secure Practice Development Consensus Forum.
London, Department of Health. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.dh.gov.uk/PublicationsAndStatistics/Publications/
PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidanceArticle/
fs/en?CONTENT_ID=4010439&chk=XB8C8w
Department of Health (2002b) 2000/2001 Survey of
Reported Violence or Abusive Incidents, Accidents Involving Staff and Sickness
Absence in NHS Trusts and Health Authorities, in England. London, Department of
Health. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.dh.gov.uk/assetRoot/04/01/47/96/04014796.pdf
Department of Health (2003) NHS Violence Survey 2003.
Accessed 30 May 2004
http://www.doh.gov.uk/public/survey-violence-nhs0203.htm
(No longer available)
Ditton J (2000) Crime and the city. Public attitudes towards open-street CCTV in Glasgow. British Journal of Criminology 40(4): 692-709.
Dixon D (1999) Beyond zero tolerance. Paper presented at the
3rd National Outlook Symposium on Crime in Australia, Mapping the
Boundaries of Australia's Criminal Justice System, convened by the Australian
Institute of Criminology, Canberra, 22-23 Mar 1999. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.aic.gov.au/conferences/outlook99/dixon.pdf
Dixon D and Coffin P (1999) Zero tolerance of illegal drug markets. Drug and Alcohol Review 18: 477-486.
Dixon D and Maher L (2005) Policing, crime and public health: lessons for Australia from 'the new York miracle'. Criminal Justice 5(2): 115-143.
Dunbar C and Villarruel FA (2004) What a difference the community makes: zero tolerance policy interpretation and implementation. Equity and Excellence in Education 37: 351-359.
Duncan S, Hyndman K, Estabrooks CA, Hesketh K, Humphrey CK, Wong JS, Acorn S, and Giovannetti P (2001) Nurses' experience of violence in Alberta and British Columbia hospitals. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 32(4): 57-78.
Duxbury J and Whittington R (2005) Causes and management of patient aggression and violence: staff and patient perspectives. Journal of Advanced Nursing 50(5): 469-478.
Ekberg G (2004) The Swedish law that prohibits the purchase of sexual services. Violence Against Women 10(10): 1187-1218.
Elston MA, Gabe J, Denney D, Lee R and O'Beirne M (2002) Violence against doctors: a medical(ised) problem? The case of National Health Service General Practitioners. Sociology of Health and Illness 24(5): 575-598.
Fay S (1998) Tough on crime, tough on civil liberties: some negative aspects of Britain's wholesale adoption of CCTV surveillance during the 1990s. International Review of Law Computers and Technology 12(2): 315-347.
Garland D (2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Grabowsky N (1999) Zero tolerance Policing. AIC Trends
and Issues Paper No 102. Canberra, Australian Institute of Criminology.
Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.aic.gov.au/publications/tandi/ti102.pdf
Giroux H (2003) Racial injustice and disposable youth in the age of zero tolerance. Qualitative Studies in Education 16(4): 553-565.
Harvard Civil Rights Project (2000) Opportunities suspended:
The devastating consequences of zero tolerance and school discipline. Harvard
Civil Rights Project. Accessed 20 Aug 2005
http://www.civilrightsproject.harvard.edu/
research/discipline/opport_suspended.php
Harvey M (1999) Howard's zero tolerance on drugs. The Advertiser 23 Feb 1999.
Heaviside S, Rowand C, Williams C, Farris E, Burns S and McArthur E (1998) Violence and Discipline Problems in US Public Schools, 1996-1997. Statistical Analysis Report, Mar 1998. National Center for Education Statistics. Accessed 19 Aug 2005 http://nces.ed.gov/pubs98/98030.pdf
Hegney D, Plank A and Parker V (2003) Workplace violence in nursing in Queensland, Australia: a self-reported study. International Journal of Nursing Studies 9: 261-268.
Herd D, Mitchell A and Lightman E (2005) Rituals of degradation: administration as policy in the Ontario Works Programme. Social Policy and Administration 39(1): 65-79.
Hubbard P (2004) Cleansing the metropolis: sex work and the politics of zero tolerance. Urban Studies 41(9): 1687-1702.
Innes M (1999) 'An iron fist in a velvet glove?' The zero tolerance policing debate. The Howard Journal 38(4): 397-410.
Jones T and Newburn T (2002) Policy convergence and crime control in the USA and the UK. Criminal Justice 2(2): 173-203.
Keith N (2000) Violence: bullying's big brother. Accident Prevention 47(3): 9-10.
Krimsky S (2003) Small gifts, conflicts of interest, and the zero-tolerance threshold in medicine. American Journal of Bioethics 3(3): 50-52.
Lees L (ed) (2004) The Emancipatory City. London, Sage.
Madge T (2003) Cards reveal the future (Editorial) Nursing Standard 17(28): 3.
Majola B (2002) Now 150 crime cameras watch the city. City
of Johannesburg official website. Accessed 4 Jun 2005
http://www.joburg.org.za/july_2002/cctv.stm
Marshall J (1999) Zero Tolerance Policing. Office of Crime Statistics Information Bulletin Issue No 9, March 1999. Adelaide, South Australia. Office of Crime Statistics.
Martin G (2003) Fighting back. The Guardian Newspaper
14 Aug. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://society.guardian.co.uk/print/0,3858,4732527-105907,00.html
Matthews R (2005) The myth of punitiveness. Theoretical Criminology 9(2): 175-201.
Mayhew C and Chappell D (2001a) 'Internal' Violence (or
Bullying) and the Health Workforce. Taskforce on the Prevention and Management
of Violence in the Health Workplace, Discussion Paper No 3. School of
Industrial Relations and Organisational Behaviour and Industrial Relations Research
Centre, University of New South Wales. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.aic.gov.au/research/cvp/docs/mayhew3.html
Mayhew C and Chappell D (2001b) Occupational Violence:
Types, Reporting Patterns, and Variations Between Health Sectors. Taskforce on
the Prevention and Management of Violence in the Health Workplace, Discussion
Paper No 1. School of Industrial Relations and Organisational Behaviour and
Industrial Relations Research Centre, University of New South Wales. Accessed
19 Aug 2005
http://www.aic.gov.au/research/cvp/docs/mayhew1.html
Mayhew C and Chappell D (2001c) Prevention of
Occupational Violence in the Health Workplace. Working paper series no 140.
Sydney, School of Industrial Relations and Organisational Behaviour and the
Industrial Relations Research Centre, University of New South Wales. Accessed 1
Jun 2005
http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention
/violence/en/wpv_australia.pdf
Mayhew C and Chappell D (2003) Workplace violence in the health sector - a case study in Australia. The Journal of Occupational Health and Safety - Australia and New Zealand 19(6): 1-43.
McKoy Y and Smith MH (2001) Legal considerations of workplace violence in healthcare environments. Nursing Forum 36(1): 5-14.
Mendez LMR (2003) Predictors of suspension and negative school outcomes: a longitudinal investigation. New Directions for Youth Development 99: 17-33.
Mulholland H (2003) Why are nurses still being attacked? Despite four years of zero tolerance, nurses still face abuse from patients. Nursing Times 99(14): 10-11.
Munro G and Midford R (2001) 'Zero tolerance' and drug education in Australian schools. Drug and Alcohol Review 20: 105-109.
National Health Service (NHS) Zero tolerance zone.
Accessed
http://www.nhs.uk/zerotolerance/
Ng B, Kumar S, Ranclaud M and Robinson E (2001) Ward Crowding and Incidents of Violence on an Acute Psychiatric Inpatient Unit. Psychiatric Services 52(4): 521-525.
NHMRC (National Health and Medical Research Council) (2002) When
it's Right in Front of You: Assisting Health Care Workers to Manage the Effects
of Violence in Rural and Remote Australia. Accessed 3rd August 2005
http://www.nhmrc.gov.au/publications/_files/hp16.pdf
Nieto M (1997) Public Video Surveillance: Is it an
Effective Crime Prevention Tool? California Research Bureau Report
CRB-97-005, California State Library. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.library.ca.gov/CRB/97/05/
NICE (National Institute for Clinical Excellence) (2005)
Clinical Practice Guidelines for Violence: The Short-term Management of
Disturbed/Violent Behaviour in Psychiatric In-patient and Emergency
Departments. Clinical Guideline #25. London, National Institute for Clinical Excellence. Accessed 19 Aug
2005
http://www.nice.org.uk/pdf/cg025fullguideline.pdf
NIMHE (National Institute for Mental Health in England)
(2004) Mental Health Policy Implementation Guide: Developing Positive
Practice to Support the Safe and Therapeutic Management of Aggression and
Violence in Mental Health In-patient Settings. London, Department of
Health. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.dh.gov.uk/
Norris C, Cahill M and Wood D (2004) Editorial. The growth of CCTV: a global perspective on the international diffusion of video surveillance in publicly accessible space. Surveillance and Society 2(2/3): 110-135.
NSW (New South Wales) Taskforce on Prevention and
Management of Violence in the Health Workforce, website: Accessed 22 Aug
2005
http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/communications/campaigns/antiviolence.html
NSW (New South Wales) Zero tolerance website
http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/health-publicaffairs/violence/
Nyman T (1999) Forget zero tolerance as an option for NSW. Law Society Journal 37(6): 60-61.
O'Brien L and Cole R (2004) Mental health nursing practice in acute psychiatric close-observation areas. International Journal of Mental Health Nursing 13: 89-99.
Peden J (2001) Through a glass darkly: educating with zero tolerance. Kansas Journal of Law & Public Policy 10: 369-389.
Peterson GM, Wu MS and Bergin JK (1999) Pharmacists' attitudes toward dispensing errors: their causes and prevention. Journal of Clinical Pharmacy and Therapeutics 24: 57-71.
Peterson RL, Larson J and Skiba S (2001) School violence prevention: current status and policy recommendations. Law and Policy 23(3): 345-371.
Pratt J (2002) Punishment and Civilization. London, Sage Publications.
Pulse (2003) GPs attack trusts over zero tolerance. 11 Aug 2004: 4.
Royal College of Nursing (RCN) (2003) RCN welcomes zero tolerance campaign but says more can be done. RCN News Online 18 Dec 2003.
Royal College of Psychiatrists (1998) Management of
Imminent Violence. Occasional Paper OP41. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.rcpsych.ac.uk/publications/guidelines/violence_full_h.htm
Royal College of Psychiatrists' Research Unit (2005)
The National Audit of Violence (2003-2005) Final Report. Healthcare Commission.
Accessed 17 Aug 2005
http://www.healthcarecommission.org.uk/assetRoot/04/01/74/51/04017451.pdf
Scottish Office (1995) Does Closed Circuit Television
Prevent Crime? An Evaluation of the Use of CCTV Surveillance in Airdrie Town
Centre. Crime and Criminal Justice Research Findings No 8, Scottish Office
Central Research Unit. Accessed 17 Aug 2005
http://www.scotland.gov.uk/cru/resfinds/crf08-00.htm
Scottish Office (1999) The Effect of Closed Circuit
Television on Recorded Crime Rates and Public Concern About Crime in Glasgow.
Crime and Criminal Justice Research Findings No 30, Scottish Office Central
Research Unit. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.scotland.gov.uk/cru/resfinds/crf08-00.htm
Secker J, Benson A, Balfe E, Lipsedge M, Robinson S and Walker J (2004) Understanding the social context of violent and aggressive incidents on an in-patient unit. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 11: 172-178.
Skiba RJ (2004) Zero tolerance: the assumptions and the facts. Education Policy Briefs 2(1): 1-7.
Skiba RJ and Noam GG (eds) (2001) Zero Tolerance: Can Suspension and Expulsion Keep Schools Safe? San Francisco, Jossey-Bass.
Skiba RJ and Peterson RL (2000) School discipline at the crossroads: from zero tolerance to early response. Exceptional Children 66(3): 335-346.
Skiba RJ, Rausch MK and Ritter S (2004) ‘Discipline is always teaching’: effective alternatives to zero tolerance in Indiana's schools. Education Policy Briefs 2(3): 1-5, 8-11.
Springen K (2001) Rethinking zero tolerance: a few schools are inching away from one-strike policies. (Special Report) Newsweek 12 Feb 2001: 46.
Sughrue JA (2003) Zero tolerance for children: two wrongs do not make a right. Educational Administration Quarterly 39(2): 238-258.
Sutton A and Wilson D (2004) Open-street CCTV in Australia: the politics of resistance and expansion. Surveillance and Society 2(2/3): 310-322.
The Guardian (2002) Zero tolerance from urban summit,
31 October 2001: 12. Accessed 1 Sept 2005
http://society.guardian.co.uk/urbandesign/story/0,11200,823580,00.html
The Guardian (2003) Swearing or loitering could be punished by jail in France, 15 Jan 2003: 11.
The Guardian (2005) Goodwill hunting, 19 January
2005. Accessed 1 Sept 2005
http://society.guardian.co.uk/mentalhealth/story/0,8150,1393159,00.html
UKCC (2001) The Recognition, Prevention and
Therapeutic Management of Violence in Mental Health Care. Prepared by the
Health Services Research Department, Institute of psychiatry, London. Accessed
19 Aug 2005
http://www.nmc-uk.org/(5xgeixnsufy31a454rhktivl)/
aFrameDisplay.aspx?DocumentID=340
Verdugo RR (2002) Race-ethnicity, social class, and zero tolerance policies: the cultural and structural wars. Education and Urban Society 35(1): 50-75.
Welsh BC and Farrington DP (2004) Evidence-based crime prevention: the effectiveness of CCTV. Crime Prevention and Community Safety: An International Journal 6(2): 21-33.
Whittington R (2002) Attitudes toward patient aggression amongst mental health nurses in the 'zero tolerance' era: associations with burnout and length of experience. Journal of Clinical Nursing 11: 819-825.
Whittington R and Higgins L (2002) More than zero tolerance? Burnout and tolerance for patient aggression among mental health nurses in China and the UK. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica 106(Suppl. 412): 37-40.
WHO, International Labour Office, International Council
of Nurses and Public Services International (2002) Framework Guidelines for
Addressing Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. Joint Programme on
Workplace Violence in the Health Sector. Geneva, WHO. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/injury/work9/en/.
Wilson JQ and Kelling GL (1982) Broken windows. The Atlantic Monthly Mar: 29-38.
Wiskow C (2003) Guidelines on Workplace Violence in the
Health Sector. Accessed 19 Aug 2005
http://www.who.int/violence_injury_prevention/violence/interpersonal/en/
WV_ComparisonGuidelines.pdf.
Wright S, Gray R, Parkes J and Gournay K (2002) The
Recognition, Prevention and Therapeutic Management of Violence in Acute
In-Patient Psychiatry: A Literature Review and Evidence-based Recommendations
for Good Practice. Report prepared for the UKCC. Accessed 20 Aug 2005
http://www.nmc-uk.org/(5j20ta552dfkolfvdhczoh55)/
aFrameDisplay.aspx?DocumentID=665.
eContent Home