Domestic Violence, Health and Health Care: Women's accounts of their experiences
Marion Tower
Associate Lecturer, School of Nursing, Griffith University, Nathan Campus, Mt Gravatt QLD
Anne M McMurray
Emeritus Professor, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Griffith University, Gold Coast, QLD; Emeritus Professor, Faculty of Health Sciences, Murdoch University, Perth, WA
Jennifer Rowe
School of Health and Sport Sciences, University of the Sunshine Coast, Maroochydore QLD
Marianne Wallis
Clinical Nursing Research, Gold Coast Health Service District; Griffith University, Southport QLD
PP: 186 - 198
Abstract
The current health service response to women's domestic violence related health issues seeks to categorise their presenting symptoms into physical and psychological ailments. This gives a narrow and somewhat simplistic focus to what is a complex phenomenon and may obscure women's experiences and limit the opportunities to provide proactive health care.
The purpose of this study was to expand knowledge about the health issues of women who are subjected to domestic violence, by affording primacy to women's accounts of health, in order to problematise current services and establish a more woman-centered underpinning for healthcare. The study involved narrative analysis of nine interviews with women who spoke about their health and health issues while they lived with domestic violence.
Findings revealed that health was complex, and that health issues were not adequately addressed by health services, in fact health care responses were implicated in further adversely affecting the health of participants. These findings illuminate patterns that underlie individual realities of health and give a foundation from which current services can be evaluated and further developed in ways that may be more sensitive to women's realities and needs.
Keywords
women, health, health care delivery, health service response, patient-centered care, domestic violence
References
Bacchus L, Mezey G and Bewley S (2003) Experiences of seeking help from health professionals in a sample of women who experienced domestic violence. Health and Social Care in the Community 11(1): 10-18.
Battaglia T, Finley E and Liebschutz J (2003) Survivors of intimate partner violence speak out. JGIM 18: 617-623.
Browne A (1993) Violence against women by men: Prevalence, outcomes and policy implications. American Psychologist 48(10): 1077-1087.
Campbell J and Soeken K (1999) Women's responses to battering: a test of the model. Research in Nursing & Health 22: 49-58.
Campbell J, Jones A, Dienemann J and Kub J et al (2002) Intimate partner violence and physical health consequences. Archives of Internal Medicine 162(10): 1157-1166.
Cheek J (2000) Postmodern and Poststructural Approaches to Nursing Research. London, Sage Publications Inc.
Coker A, Smith P, Bethea L, King M and McKeown R (2000) Physical health consequences of physical and psychological intimate partner violence. Archives of Family Medicine 9: 451-457.
Cole T (1999) Case management for domestic violence. JAMA 282(6): 513-514.
Davis R and Harsh K (2001). Confronting barriers to universal screening for domestic violence. Journal of Professional Nursing 17(6): 313-320.
DeKeseredy W and Schwartz M (1998) Measuring the extent of woman abuse in intimate heterosexual relationships: a critique of the conflict tactics scale. Retrieved May 21 2003 from National Electronic Network on Violence Against Women web site http://www.vaw.umn.edu.
Dienemann J, Boyle E, Baker D, Resnick W, Wiederhorn N and Campbell J (2000) Intimate partner abuse among women diagnosed with depression. Issues in Mental Health Nursing 21: 499-513.
Dyehouse J (1992) Abuse of women in the health care system. In Sampselle C (ed) Violence Against Women: Nursing Research, Education & Practice Issues (pp.219-234). USA: Hemisphere Publishing Corporation.
Emden C (1998) Conducting a narrative analysis. Collegian 5(3): 34-39.
Fraser K (2003) Domestic violence and women's physical health. Retrieved January 9 2004 from http://www.austdvclearinghouse.unsw.edu.au.
Garcia-Moreno C (2002) Dilemmas and opportunities for an appropriate health-service response to violence against women, The Lancet 359(9316): 1509-1514.
Gerbert B, Abercrombie P, Caspers N, Love C and Bronstone A (1999) How health care providers help battered women: the survivor's perspective. Women & Health 29(3): 115-135.
Glass N and Davis K (1998) An emancipatory impulse: a feminist postmodern integrated turning point in nursing research. Advances in Nursing Science 21(1): 43-54.
Griffin M and Koss M (2002 January 31) Clinical screening and intervention in cases of domestic violence. Online Journal of Issues in Nursing 7, No 1. Retrieved October 3 2002 from http://www.nursingworld.org/ojin/topic17/tpc17_2.htm.
Guth A and Pachter L (2000) Domestic violence and the trauma surgeon. The American Journal of Surgery 179: 134-140.
Hall J and Stevens P (1991) Rigor in feminist research. Advances in Nursing Science 13(3): 16-29.
Hegarty K, Hindmarsh E and Gilles M (2001) Domestic violence in Australia: definition, prevalence and nature of presentation in clinical practice. Medical Journal of Australia 173: 363-367.
Henderson A (2001) Factors influencing nurses' responses to abused women. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 16(12): 1284-1306.
Horner D (2000) Domestic violence among female patients in general practice surgeries on Sydney's North Shore: estimates, reported prevalence and attitudes toward disclosure. Retrieved January 9 2004 from http://www.austdvclearinghouse.unsw.edu.au.
Humphreys C and Thiara R (2003) Mental Health and domestic violence: I call it symptoms of abuse. British Journal of Social Work 33: 209-226.
Im E (2000) A feminist critique of research on women's work and health. Health Care for Women International 21: 105-119.
Mazza D, Dennerstein L and Ryan V (1996) Physical, sexual and emotional violence against women: a general practice-based prevalence study. Medical Journal of Australia 164: 14-17.
Mazza D, Dennerstein L, Garamszegi C and Dudley E (2001) The physical, sexual and emotional violence history of middle-aged women: a community-based prevalence study. MJA 175: 199-201.
McCauley J, Kern D, Kolodner K, Dill L, Schroeder A, DeChant H, Ryden J, Bass E and Derogates L (1995) The ‘Battering Syndrome’: Prevalence and clinical characteristics of domestic violence in primary care internal medicine practices. Annals of Internal Medicine 123(10): 737-746.
McMurray A (2005) Domestic violence: Conceptual and Practice Issues, Contemporary Nurse 18(3): 219-232.
McNutt L, Carlson B, Persaud M and Postmus J (2002) Cumulative abuse experiences, physical health and health behaviours. Annals of Epidemiology 12(2): 123-130.
Meleis A, Arrunda E, Lane S and Bernal P (1994) Veiled, voluminous and devalued: narrative stories about low-income women from Brazil, Egypt and Colombia. Advances in Nursing Science 17(2): 1-15.
Mischler E (1986) Research Interviewing: Context and Narrative. London: Harvard University Press.
National Health & Medical Research Council (1999) National Statement on Ethical Conduct in Research Involving Humans. Canberra, AGPS.
Parker G and Lee C (2002) Violence and abuse: an assessment of mid-aged Australian women's experiences. Australian Psychologist 37(2): 142-148.
Pease B (1996) Naming violence as a gender issue. Women Against Violence: An Australian Feminist Journal. November: 33-39.
Perley M (1992) Health care agency support for nursing intervention in violence against women. In Sampselle C (ed) Violence Against Women: Nursing Research, Education, Practice & Issues (pp.3-16). USA, Hemisphere Publishing Corporation.
Petersen R, Gazmararian J, and Andersen K (2001) Partner violence: implications for health and community settings. Women's Health Issues 11(2): 116-125.
Plichta S and Falik M (2001) Prevalence of violence and its implications for women's health. Women's Health Issues 11 (3): 244-258.
Poirer S and Ayres L (1997) Endings, secrets, and silences: overreading in narrative inquiry. Research in Nursing & Health 20: 551-557.
Porcerelli J, Cogan R, West P, Rose E, Lambrecht D, Wilson K, Severson R and Karana D (2003) Violent victimisation of women and men: physical and psychiatric symptoms. Journal of American Board of Family Practitioners 16(1): 32-39.
Putman Tong R (1998) Feminist Thought: A More Comprehensive Introduction. St Leonard's, NSW, Allen & Unwin.
Roberts G, Lawrence J, O'Toole B and Raphael B. (1997) Domestic violence in the Emergency department: I, two case-control studies of victims. General Hospital Psychiatry 19: 5-11.
Roberts K and Taylor B (2002) Nursing Research Process: An Australian Perspective. Victoria, Nelson Australia Pty Ltd.
Roughton S (2000) Domestic violence: assessing and improving inter-agency work. Community Practitioner 73(6): 647-649.
Sampselle C (1991) The role of nursing in preventing violence against women. JOGNN 20(6): 481-486.
Stark E (2001) Health interventions with battered women. In Rinzetti C, Edleson J and Bergen R (eds) Sourcebook on Violence Against Women (pp.345-369). California, Sage Publications Inc.
Stevens P (1993). Marginalized women's access to health care: A feminist narrative analysis. Advances in Nursing Science 16(2): 39-56.
Sutherland C, Bybee D and Sullivan C (2002) Beyond bruises and broken bones: the joint effects of stress and injuries on battered women's health. American Journal of Community Psychiatry 30(5): 609-637.
Taft A (2003) Promoting women's mental health: the challenges of intimate /domestic violence against women (Issues Paper 8). Sydney: Australian Domestic and Family Violence Clearinghouse, UNSW Sydney.
Varcoe C (2001) Abuse obscured: an ethnographic account of emergency nursing in relation to violence against women. Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 32(4): 95-101.
Walton-Moss B and Campbell J (2002 January 31) Intimate partner violence: implications for nursing. Online Journal of Issues in Nursing 7, No 1. Retrieved October 3 2002 from http://www.nursingworld.org/ojin/topic17/tpc17_2.htm.
Warshaw C (1993) Limitations of the medical model in the care of battered women. In Bart P and Moran E (eds) Violence Against Women: The Bloody Footprints (pp.135-146). California, Sage Publications Inc.
Woodtli A (2001) Nurses' attitudes toward survivors and perpetrators of domestic violence. Journal of Holistic Nursing 19(4): 340-359.
eContent Home
