Acute health care and Australia's ethnic people
Olga Kanitsaki
Department of Nursing and Midwifery, RMIT University, Melbourne VIC
PP: 122 - 127
Abstract
At some stage, people of non-English speaking background (NESB) living in Australia will require acute health care. This in itself is not particularly remarkable or problematic; however, as the mainstream services available to the community are essentially monocultural (ie reflect the domination of Anglo-Australian cultural values), it is questionable as to whether the unique needs of Australia's culturally diverse people are being met.
The discussion will focus on some of the problems encountered by people of NESB and/or culturally different backgrounds in acute health care services. Nursing as a profession defends rigorously the notions of holistic and morally accountable nursing practice. For my part, it is difficult to accept that unacceptable nursing attitudes and practices toward patients of culturally different backgrounds have been tolerated by the nursing profession - not least, in its failure to correct them, and by virtue of its silence which has, until recently, tacitly validated them.
While it might be said that the case studies presented here are few and limited, I am sad to say that there are many other similar examples (see Johnstone & Kanitsaki 1991a, Kanitsaki 1989a, 1983, Parsons 1990). Certainly these cases 'speak for themselves' in depicting a range of unacceptable nursing behaviours.
References
Australian Institute of Multicultural Affairs (1986) Community and institutional care for aged migrants in Australia. Globe Press, Melbourne.
Advisory Committee to the Multicultural Nursing Workforce Project (1991) Responding to a multicultural society: Issues and strategies for nurse education. Office of Ethnic Affairs and Ethnic Health Unit Health Department, Melbourne, Victoria.
Alcorso C and Schofield T (1992) The national non-English speaking background women's health strategy. Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra.
Benner P (1984) From novice to expert. Addison-Wesley, California.
Benner P and Wrubel J (1989) The primacy of caring. Addison-Wesley, California.
Bertelli L (1978) The immigrant woman and the hospital: A draft bibliography. CHOMI (Reprints). Clearing House on Migration Issues, Melbourne.
Castles et al (1988) Mistaken identity: Multiculturalism and the demise of nationalism in Australia. Pluto Press, Sydney.
D'Cruz JV and Tham G (1993) Nursing and nursing education in multicultural Australia: A Victorian study of some cultural, curriculum and demographic issues. David Lovell Publishing, Melbourne.
Helman C (1990) Culture, health and illness. John Wright, Bristol.
Johnstone M J (1992) Personal communication.
Johnstone MJ and Kanitsaki O (1991a) Some moral implications of cultural and linguistic diversity in health care. Bioethics News 10(2): 22-32.
Johnstone MJ and Kanitsaki O (1991b) Rationalisation of interpreter services for NESP and health care: A question of human rights. Health Issues 27(June): 9-12.
Kanitsaki O (1983) Acculturation - A new dimension in nursing. Australian Nurses Journal 13(5): 42-45, 53.
Kanitsaki O (1988) Transcultural nursing a challenge to change. Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 5(3): 3-ll.
Kanitsaki O (1989a) 'An investigation into the health-illness-suffering experiences of a sample of Greek-born members of 12 Greek families living in Melbourne'. Partially published thesis submitted as partial fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Master of Education Studies. December Monash University, Melbourne.
Kanitsaki O (1989b) Towards a transcultural approach to the education of health professionals and to health care delivery in Victoria. Proceedings of the Conference on Cross-cultural Communication in the Health Professions. National Centre for Community Languages in the Professions Monash University, Melbourne, pp.94-100.
Kanitsaki O (1992a) Transcultural nursing: A teaching package for lecturers. Department of Nursing, School of Health Sciences La Trobe University, Melbourne.
Kanitsaki O (1992b) Meeting the challenge of patients rights: A transcultural perspective. Proceedings of the Conference on Nursing Law and Ethics, 4th Victorian State conference: Meeting the challenge of patients rights-Issues for the 1990s. RMIT Faculty of Nursing, Melbourne, Victoria.
Kanitsaki O (1993) Transcultural human care: Its challenge to and critique of professional nursing care. In Gaut DA (ed) A global agenda for caring. National League for Nursing Press, New York.
Leininger M (1984) Care: The essence of nursing and health. Slack, Thorofare.
Leininger M (ed) (1988) Caring: An essential human need. Wayne State University Press, Detroit.
Minas H (1989) Cross-cultural communication in mental health settings: Proceedings of the Conference on Cross-cultural Communication in the Health Professions. National Centre for Community Languages in the Professions. Monash University Melbourne, pp.78-88.
Minas H (1990) Mental health in a culturally diverse society. In Reid J and Trompf P (eds) The health of immigrant Australia: A social perspective. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Sydney.
Moraitis S (1972) Medico-social problems in the Greek population in Melbourne: Paediatric problems as seen by the medical practitioner. Medical Journal of Australia 2(16):881-883.
Moraitis S (1977) Greek ethnic attitudes in Australia. Australian Family Physician 6:853-859.
Parsons C (1990) Cross-cultural issues in health care. In Reid J and Trompf P (eds) The health of immigrant Australia: A social perspective. Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Sydney.
Piperoglou MV (1988) The stress of change: The Greek migrant experience. Australian Family Physician 17(6):453-456.
Retchford F (1972) Medico-social problems in the Greek population in Melbourne: Social work experience in public hospitals. Medical Journal of Australia 2(16):883-885.
Report of the Ministerial Taskforce on Ethnic Health (1991) An agenda for change. Health Services and Ethnic Communities. Health Department Victoria, Melbourne.
Roy C (1984) Introduction to nursing: An adaptation model 2nd edn. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs NJ.
Watson J (1979) Nursing: The philosophy and science of caring. Little Brown, Boston.
Watson J (1985) Nursing: Human science and human care, a theory of nursing. Appleton- Century-Crofts/Norwalk, Connecticut.
eContent Home
