Archives
Tradition, Rituals and Standards, in a Realm of Evidenced Based Nursing Care
Kathryn Zeitz
State Nursing Officer (SA) St John Ambulance; PhD Candidate, Department of Clinical Nursing, University of Adelaide, Adelaide SA
Helen McCutcheon
Deputy Head, Department of Clinical Nursing, University of Adelaide, Adelaide SA
Abstract
Evidenced-based nursing is seen as the future of nursing but the
real world in which practice occurs is limiting the possibilities for
change. The practice of post-operative (PO) vital sign collection in
the general ward setting is described as an example of the complexities
that surround practice.
Despite the ongoing work around evidenced-based practice, elements
of nursing practice remain based on tradition. Routines and rituals are
driving care rather than clinical judgement. The complexities of
practice limit the possibilities for change. These complexities include
the systems in which nurses' practice, the fear of medico-legal
repercussions, and the sense of security that rituals provide.
This paper discusses these themes including the barriers to change
and the implications for practice. The development of evidenced-based
practice is only one component of the solution to the provision of best
practice. Care is required to ensure that the evidenced-based movement
does not lead to recipe book care rather than patient centred practice.
Keywords
post-operative vital signs, ritualised practice, clinical judgement, evidenced-based practice, standards
Navigate: Archives | Contents | Top of page
Web Feed
Latest Articles
Call for Papers
Advances in Contemporary Nursing and Midwifery History in Australasia
Volume 30/2
Deadline: Closed
Advances in Contemporary Nurse Education
Volume 32/1-2
Deadline: 30th Sep 2008
Advances in Contemporary Nursing and Gender
Volume 33/2
Deadline: 15th Dec 2008
Advances in Contemporary Mental Health Nursing – Second Edition
Volume 34/1
Deadline: 2nd Mar 2009
Advances in Contemporary Modeling of Clinical Nursing Care
Volume 35/1
Deadline: 30th Apr 2009
Special Issues
Advances in Contemporary Modeling of Clinical Nursing Care
Vol 35/1, 1st Apr 2010
Advances in Contemporary Mental Health Nursing – Second Edition
Vol 34/1, 1st Dec 2009
Advances in Contemporary Nursing and Gender
Vol 33/2, 1st Oct 2009
Advances in Contemporary Nurse Education
Vol 32/1-2, 1st Apr 2009
Advances in Contemporary Nursing and Midwifery History in Australasia
Vol 30/2, 1st Oct 2008
Advances in Contemporary Transcultural Nursing (2nd edn)
Vol 28/1-2, 15th Apr 2008
Advances in Contemporary Palliative and Supportive Care
Vol 27/1, 1st Dec 2007
Advances in Contemporary Aged Care: Retirement to End of Life
Vol 26/2, 1st Oct 2007
Advances in Contemporary General Practice Nursing: Role of the Practice Nurse
Vol 26/1, 1st Aug 2007
Advances in Contemporary Nurse Recruitment and Retention
Vol 24/2, 1st Apr 2007
Advances in Contemporary Community and Family Health Care
Vol 23/2, 1st Jan 2007
Advances in Contemporary Indigenous Health Care
Vol 22/2, 1st Sep 2006
Advances in Contemporary Nursing & Interpersonal Violence
Vol 21/2, 1st May 2006
Advances in Contemporary Mental Health Nursing
Vol 21/1, 1st Mar 2006
Advances in Contemporary Child and Family Care
Vol 18/1-2, 1st Jan 2005
Advances in Contemporary Transcultural Nursing
Vol 15/3, 1st Oct 2003