Teaching and breast self-examination: An insufficiency of instruction
Beverley J Turnbull
School of Health Sciences, Charles Darwin University, Darwin NT
Kathryn L Roberts
Professor of Nursing, Flinders University, SA
PP: 167 - 176
Abstract
Client teaching is recognised as an essential component of nursing and midwifery care, and all clinical areas provide opportunities for informal client teaching.
This qualitative study aimed to explore registered nurses' professional practices with regard to teaching breast self-examination (BSE), and to identify factors that influenced their participation or non-participation in teaching about breast health. Participants' views were obtained using individual semi-structured interviews. The data were analysed inductively, that is, without imposing structure from the interview questions.
Findings revealed that participants' perspectives of BSE and breast health, the dual symbolism of breasts, and the time constraints of clinical practice, were significant factors that impacted on participants' personal BSE practices and on their level of participation in teaching BSE.
The results indicate that that nurses and midwives do not view teaching breast health as part of their role in client interaction, particularly in an acute care setting. Although nursing literature identifies midwives and nurses as ideally placed to promote health promotion activities, the image of BSE as linked to breast cancer, the dominant illness oriented model of care and a task orientated culture in health care facilities do not facilitate this.
Keywords
nurses and midwives; BSE; breast symbolism; breast cancer; health promotion
References
Bailey K (2000): The nurse's role in promoting breast awareness. Nursing Standard 14(30): 34-6.
Brain R (1979): The Decorated Body. New York, Harper & Row.
Brucker M and Scharbo-Dehaan M (1991): The Role of the Nurse-Midwife. Journal of Nurse- Midwifery 36(1): 63-73.
Budden L (1998): Registered nurses' teaching self-examination practice and teaching to female clients. Journal of Community Health Nursing 15(2): 101-12.
Cantrell J (1997): Health education and patient education: literature review and management issues. Managing Clinical Nursing 1(11): 14.
Carter P (1995): Feminism, Breasts and Breast- Feeding. London, MacMillan Press.
Clarke D and Sandler L (1989): Factors involved in nurses' teaching breast self-examination. Cancer Nursing 12(1): 41-46.
Clarke V, Hill D, Rassaby J, White V and Hirst S (1991): Determinants of continued breast self-examination practice in women forty years and over after personalised instruction. Health Education Research: Theory and Practice 6(3): 297-306.
Coleman E (1991): Practice and effectiveness of breast self examination: a selective review of the literature (1977-1989). Journal of Cancer Education 6(2): 83-92.
Crossing S and Manaszewicz R (2003): Breast self examination: be alert but not alarmed? Medical Journal of Australia 178(12): 646-647.
Devine S and Frank D (2000): Nurses self-performing and teaching others breast self-examination: implications for practice. Clinical Excellence for Nurse Practitioners 4(4): 216-23.
Donaldson N, Rutledge D and Pravikoff D (1999): Principles for effective adult focused patient education in nursing. Online Journal of Clinical Innovations 2(2): 1-22.
Ellis A, Slavin A and Pinch C (1990): Breast self-examination: A teaching role for nurses. Australian Nurses Journal 19(11): 16-17.
Forrest (1986): Forrest Report - Breast Cancer Screening: a report to the Health Ministers of England, Wales, Scotland and Ireland, Department of Health and Social Security.
Hall J (1997): Breastfeeding and sexuality: societal conflicts and expectations. British Journal of Midwifery 5(6): 350-354.
Hallal J (1982): The relationship of health beliefs, health locus of control, and self concept to the practice of breast self-examination in adult women. Nursing Research 31(3): 137-142.
Han S, Baumann L and Cimprich B (1996): Factors influencing registered nurses teaching breast self examination to female clients. Cancer Nursing 19(3): 197-203.
Heyman E, Tyner R, Phipps C, Cave L and Owen D (1991): Is the hospital the setting for the place for teaching breast self-examination? Cancer Nursing 14(1): 35-40.
Hill D, Jamrocik K, White V, Collins J, Boyages J, Shugg D, Pruden M, Giles G and Byrne M (1999): Surgical management of breast cancer in Australia in 1995: a literature review. Sydney, NHMRC National Breast Cancer Centre. Available at: http://www.nbcc.org.au/pages/info/resource/nbccpubs/brselfexam/lit_contents.htm (accessed April, 2004)
Hirst S (1986): Breast self examination: nurses' personal and professional practices. The Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 3(4): 42-47.
Lauver D, Kane J, Bodden J, McNeel J and Smith L (1999): Engagement in breast cancer screening behaviours. Oncology Nursing Forum 26(3): 545-554.
Lierman L, Kasprzyk D and Benoleil J (1991): Understanding adherence to breast self examination in older women. Western Journal of Nursing Research 13(1): 46-66.
Luxford, Y (2003):Troublesome breasts: older women living in the liminal state of being 'at risk' of breast cancer. Health Sociology Review 12(2): 146-154
Marks M (1985): Breast self examination. The Practitioner 229 (March): 225-229.
McConville B (1994): Mixed Messages, our breasts in our lives. London, Penguin Books.
National Breast Cancer Centre (1999): Breast self-examination and the early detection of breast cancer: a summary of the evidence for health professionals, NBCC. Available at: http://www.nbcc.org.au/info/resource/nbccpubs/brselfexam/lit_refs.htm (accessed April, 2004)
National Breast Cancer Centre (2003) Screening and early detection, NBCC. Available at: http://www.nbcc.org.au/bestpractice/screening/index.html (accessed April 2004)
Nekhlyudov I and Fletcher S (2001): Is it time to stop teaching breast self-examination? Canadian Medical Association Journal 164(13): 1851-1852.
National Health and Medical Research Council (1995): Clinical Practice Guidelines. The Management of Early Breast Cancer. Sydney, NH&MRC
Outhred J (1994): Teaching Nurses. Nursing New Zealand (September): 13-15.
Patton M (1990): Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods. Newbury Park California, Sage.
Pearson K, Johansson I and Ek A (1995): Breast self-examination among Swedish women: a survey of frequency, knowledge, and attitudes. Journal of Cancer Nursing 10(3): 163-167.
Rafferty D (1995): Putting sexuality on the agenda. Nursing Times 91(17): 28-31.
Rice P and Ezzy D (1999): Qualitative Research Methods. A Health Focus. Melbourne, Oxford.
Roberts K and Taylor B (2002): Nursing Research Processes: An Australian Perspective. Melbourne, Thomas Nelson.
Russell R (1990): From Nightingale to Now: Nurse Education in Australia. Sydney, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Schlueter L (1982): Knowledge and beliefs about breast cancer and breast self-examination among athletic and non-athletic women. Nursing Research 31(6): 348-353.
Stamler L, Thomas B, Lafreniere K and Charbonneau-Smith R (2001):Women's perceptions of breast cancer screening and education opportunities in Canada. Canadian Nurse 97(9): 23-27.
Sundquist K (1993): Identity and symbol. Sexuality and breast cancer. On the Level. A Healthrites Publication 2(2): 33-35.
Turnbull B (2004): Breast health: paradoxes in image, symbolism, and practice. Collegian 11(1): 17-20.
Wellard S, Turner D and Bethune E (1998): Nurses as patient-teachers: Exploring current expressions of the role. Contemporary Nurse 1998(7): 12-17.
Whitehead D (2000): Using mass media within health promoting practice: a nursing perspective. Journal of Advanced Nursing 32(4): 807-16.
Yalom M (1998): A History of the Breast. New York, Pandora.
eContent Home
