Is compassion essential to nursing practice?
Marit Helene Hem
Research Fellow, Section for Health Science, Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, Norway
Kristen Heggen
Associate Professor, Section for Health Science, Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo, Norway
PP: 019 - 031
Abstract
In 2001 the Norwegian Nurses' Association approved a new code of ethics that included compassion as one of the basic values in nursing care.
This paper examines the idea of compassion in the context of the Bible story of the Good Samaritan using an analysis of qualitative data from nurses' clinical work with psychiatric patients. The aim is to show how the idea of compassion challenges nursing practice. Thereafter, the paper discusses the benefits of and premises for compassion in care work.
The results show that nurses tend not to be guided by compassion in their work with patients. The organisation of the day-to-day work in the hospital ward, the division of labour between nurses and doctors, and the nurses' approach to nursing were identified as influencing this tendency. The study shows that compassion is a radical concept with a potential to promote greater respect for patients' dignity.
Keywords
caring; code of ethics; compassion; dignity; psychiatric nursing; The Good Samaritan
References
The New English Bible
Beech P & Norman I (1995): Patients' perceptions of the quality of psychiatric nursing care: findings from a small-scale descriptive study. Journal of Clinical Nursing 4, 117-123.
Benedetti G (1974): Klinisk psykoterapi (Clinical psychotherapy). Cappelen, Oslo, Norway.
Bray J (1999): An ethnographic study of psychiatric nursing. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 6, 297-305.
Clarke L (1996): Participant observation in a secure unit: care, conflict and control. Nursing Times Research 6, 431-441.
Cleary M & Edwards C (1999): 'Something always comes up': nurse-patient interaction in an acute psychiatric setting. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 6, 469-477.
Dahlgren L (1996): Fältforskning - En distanslös eller distanserande verksamhet? (Field research - an activity that creates or abolishes distance?) In: Svensson P-G & Starrin B (eds.) Kvalitativa studier i teori och praktikk (Qualitative studies in theory and practice), pp. 79-99. Studentlitteratur, Lund, Sweden.
Delaney K, Ulsafer-Van Lanen J, Pitula C R & Johnson M E (1995): Seven days and counting: how inpatient nurses might adjust their practice to brief hospitalization. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing 33, 36-40.
Emrich K (1989): Helping or Hurting? Interacting in the psychiatric milieu. Journal of Psychosocial Nursing 27, 26-29.
Forchuk C (1995): Uniqueness within the nurse-client relationship. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, IX, 34-39.
Foucault M (1965/1988): Madness and civilization. A history of insanity in the age of reason. Vintage Books, New York.
Gallop R, Lance W J & Garfinkel P (1990): The expressed empathy of psychiatric nursing staff. The Canadian Journal of Nursing Research 22, 7-18.
Gijbels H (1995): Mental health nursing skills in an acute admission environment: perceptions of mental health nurses and other mental health professionals. Journal of Advanced Nursing 21, 460-465.
Hammersley M & Atkinson P (1996): Feltmetodikk. Grunnlaget for feltarbeid og feltforskning (Field methodology. Foundations of fieldwork and field research). Ad Notam Gyldendal, Oslo, Norway.
Hansen H P (1995): Feltarbejde som forskningsstrategi (Fieldwork as a research strategy). In: Lunde I M & Ramhøj P (eds.) Humanistisk forskning inden for sundhedsvidenskab (Humanistic research in health science), pp. 116-128.Akademisk Forlag, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Hansen K M (2001): Den barmhjertige samaritan - førstehjelp i veikanten (The Good Samaritan - First aid at the wayside). In: Breder A-B A & Nordahl H (eds.) Barmhjertighet og rettferdighet (Compassion and justice), pp. 13-38.Verbum, Oslo, Norway.
Heggen K & Fjell T I (1998): Etnografi (Ethnography). In: Lorensen M (ed.) Spørsmålet bestemmer metoden. Forskningsmetoder i sykepleie og andre helsefag (The question determines the method. Research methods in nursing and other areas of public health), pp. 66-90. Universitetsforlaget, Oslo, Norway.
Heggen K (2000): Romantisering av sykepleiefaget (Romanticising the nursing profession). Tidsskriftet Sykepleien. Internet: http://www.sykepleien.no/artikler/2000/01/a03/artikel.htm
Heggen K (2002): Krenkende pleie og behandling (Care and therapy that violates the patient's dignity). In: Sætersdal B & Heggen K (eds.) I den beste hensikt? 'Ondskap' i behandlingssamfunnet (Well-meaning? 'Evil' in the therapeutic society), pp. 33-57.Akribe Forlag, Oslo, Norway.
Hellzén O, Norberg A & Sandman P O (1995): Schizophrenic patients' image of their carers and the carers' image of their patients: an interview study. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 2, 279-285.
Hem M H (2000): 'Vil du være min venn?' En studie av dilemmaer i relasjoner mellom psykiatriske sykepleiere og psykotiske pasienter i en akuttpsykiatrisk avdeling ('Do you want to be my friend?' A study of dilemmas influencing the psychiatric nurse-psychotic patient relationship in psychiatric acute wards). Master Degree Thesis. Seksjon for helsefag, Det medisinske fakultet, Universitetet i Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
Hem M H & Heggen K (2003): Being professional and being human: one nurse's relationship with a psychiatric patient. Journal of Advanced Nursing 43 (1): 101-108.
Hem M H & Heggen K (2004): Rejection - a neglected phenomenon in psychiatric nursing. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing. In press.
Henriksen J-O & Vetlesen A J (1997): Nærhet og distanse. Grunnlag, verdier og etiske teorier i arbeid med mennesker (Closeness and distance. Foundations of work with human beings, values and ethical theories).Ad Notam Gyldendal, Oslo, Norway.
Henriksson B-G & Månsson S-A (1996): Deltagande observation (Participant observation). In: Svensson P-G & Starrin B (eds.) Kvalitativa studier i teori och praktikk (Qualitiative studies in theory and practice), pp. 11-51. Studentlitteratur, Lund, Sweden.
Holstein B (1995):Triangulering - metoderedskap og validitetsinstrument (Triangulation - methodological tool and validatory instrument). In: Lunde I M & Ramhøj P (eds.) Humanistisk forskning inden for sundhedsvidenskab (Humanistic research in health science), pp. 329-338.Akademisk Forlag, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Hummelvoll J K & Røsset O (1999): De nødvendige idealer og de slitsomme realiteter. Fokus på akuttpsykiatrien (The necessary ideals and the exhausting realities. Focus on acute psychiatry). Rapport nr. 17. Høgskolen i Hedmark, Elverum, Norway.
Kleinman A (1988): The illness narratives. Suffering, healing and the human condition. Basic Books, Inc., New York, U.S.A.
Kvale S (1995): Den sociale konstruktion af validitet (The social construction of validity). In: Lunde I M & Ramhøj P (eds.) Humanistisk forskning inden for sundhedsvidenskap (Humanistic research health science), pp. 295-314. Akademisk Forlag, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Latour B (1987): Science in action: How to follow scientists and engineers through society. Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
Lepola I & Vanhanen L (1997): The patient's daily activities in acute psychiatric care. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 4, 29-36.
Lindström U Å (1997): Patientens upplevelse av vårdkultur och vårdrelation - motsatsernes dialektik (The Patient's Experience with Caring Culture and Caring Relation - The Dialectic of Contradictions). In: Nordiska perspektiv på psykiatrisk omvårdnad (Scandinavian Perspectives on Psychiatric Nursing). (eds Hummelvoll J. K. & Lindström U. Å.), pp. 73-94. Studentlitteratur, Lund, Sweden.
Martinsen K (1989): Omsorg, sykepleie og medisin (Care, nursing and medicine).Tano, Oslo, Norway.
Martinsen K (1993): Fra Marx til Løgstrup. Om etikk og sanselighet i sykepleien (From Marx to Løgstrup. On ethics and awareness in nursing). Tano, Oslo, Norway.
Martinsen K (1996): Fenomenologi og omsorg.Tre dialoger (Phenomenology and care.Three dialogues). Tano Aschehoug, Oslo, Norway.
Menzies I E P (1960): A case-study in the functioning of social systems as a defence against anxiety. A report on a study of the nursing service of a general hospital. Human Relations 13, 95-121.
Mereness D A & Taylor C M (1982): Mereness' Essentials on Psychiatric Nursing. The C.V. Mosby Company, St. Louis.
Müller A & Poggenpoel M (1996): Patients' Internal World Experience of Interacting With Psychiatric Nurses. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing X, 143-150.
Nortvedt P (1998): Sykepleiens grunnlag: historie, fag og etikk. (Nursing: history, profession and ethics).Tano Aschehoug, Oslo, Norway.
Nortvedt P (2000): Må sykepleien 'avromantiseres'? (Must we deromanticise nursing?) Tidsskriftet Sykepleien. Internet: http://www.sykepleien.no/artikler/2000/04/a09/artikel.htm
Nortvedt P (2002): Barmhjertighet og yrkesetikk (Mercy and ethics of the professions). Tidsskriftet Sykepleien 7:31.
Pejlert A, Asplund K & Norberg A (1995): Stories about living in a hospital ward as narrated by schizophrenic patients. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 2, 269-277.
Pellegrino E D (1979): Humanism and the physician. University of Tennessee Press, Knoxville.
Pellegrino E D and Thomasma D (1981): A philosophical basis of medical practice: Toward a philosophy and ethics of the healing professions. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Peplau H. (1992) Interpersonal relations: A theoretical framework for application in nursing practice. Nursing Science Quarterly 5, 13-18.
Porter S. (1992) Institutional restraints upon education reforms: the case of mental health nursing. Nursing Education Today 12, 452-457.
Ramhøj P (1993): Fortællingen og dens muligheder i sygeplejeforskningen (Narrative and its possibilities in nursing research). In: Lunde I M & Ramhøj P (eds). Overvejelser og metoder i sundhedsforskningen (The issues and methods in health research), pp. 85-103. Akademisk Forlag, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Ryrie I, Agunbiade D, Brannock L & Maris-Shaw A (1998): A survey of psychiatric nursing practice in two inner city acute admission wards. Journal of Advanced Nursing 27, 848-854.
Savage J (1995): Nursing intimacy: an ethnographic approach to nurse-patient interaction, pp. 1-27. Scutari Press, London, UK.
Schafer P (1997): When a client develops an attraction: successful resolution versus boundary violation. Journal of Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing 4, 203-211.
Solbakk J H (1998): Etiske sider ved medisinsk og helsefaglig forskning (Ethical aspects of medical and health research). In: Lorensen M (ed.) Spørsmålet bestemmer metoden. Forskningsmetoder i sykepleie og andre helsefag (The question determines the method. Research methods in nursing and other areas of public health), pp. 312-332. Universitetsforlaget, Oslo, Norway.
Stuart G W & Sundeen S J (1991): Principles and practice of psychiatric nursing. The C.V. Mosby Company, St. Louis.
Svensson P-G (1996): Förståelse, trovärdighet eller validitet? (Understanding, credibility or validity?) In: Svensson P-G & Starrin B (eds.) Kvalitativa studier i teori och praktikk (Qualitative studies in theory and practice), pp. 209-227. Studentlitteratur, Lund, Sweden.
Travelbee J (1971): Interpersonal aspects of nursing. Davis Company, Philadelphia.
Toombs K (2001): Handbook of phenomenology and medicine. Kluwer, Dordrecht.
Wadel C (1991): Feltarbeid i egen kultur - en innføring i kvalitativt orientert samfunnsforskning. (Fieldwork in one's own culture - an introduction to qualitative orientations in social research) SEEK A/S, Flekkefjord, Norway.
Yrkesetiske retningslinjer for sykepleiere (Code of ethics for nurses). Norsk Sykepleierforbund, 2001. Internet: http://www.nosf.no
Zaner R M (1993): Troubled voices: Stories of Ethics and Illness. The Pilgrim Press, Cleveland.
eContent Home
