Community health nursing in Australia: A critical literature review and implications for professional development
Kim Brookes
Clinical Nurse Consultant, St George Hospital, Sydney South East Illawarra Area Health Service, School of Nursing, University of Western Sydney, Sydney NSW
Patricia M Davidson
Centre of Cardiovascular and Chronic Care, School of Nursing and Midwifery, University of Technology Sydney, Sydney NSW; Curtin University, Perth WA
John Daly
Faculty of Nursing, Midwifery and Health; WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Development, University of Technology Sydney, Sydney NSW
Karen Hancock
Research Fellow, University of Western Sydney, NSW
PP: 195 - 207
Abstract
Background
Increasing emphasis on community-based care mandates an examination of the community health nurse (CHN).
Aim
A critical literature review of the CHN role internationally, with an emphasis on Australia, was undertaken in order to understand historical precedents and inform policy and strategic directions for the CHN.
Method
A search of the CINAHL, EMBASE, and COCHRANE electronic data-bases from 1982 to June 2002 using 'community' and 'nursing' as key words and hand searching of books and government reports was undertaken.
Findings
This search strategy revealed a lack of literature compared with other areas of nursing. Key themes emerging from this review are: (1) an absence of clear role definitions and lack of clarity of roles; (2) variability in educational requirements for CHNs; (3) diminished CHN power in policy decision making; (3) conflicting role expectations between different facets of the health care system; (4) underutilisation and untapped potential of the role of the CHN in the contemporary health care system; (5) the emerging influence of specialist nurses in community based-care; (6) uptake of traditional nursing roles by non-nurses and (7) an absence of a cohesive model of professional development of CHN that is able to articulate with contemporary social, political and economic trends in health care delivery.
Conclusions
Community health nursing in Australia has a low professional profile when compared to other nursing specialties. An emerging issue, gleaned from the literature review is the tension and debate between specialist and generalist services. It is apparent from this review that CHN have to more actively participate in research and peer reviewed debate in order to have their voice heard and promote their unique and valuable contribution to the nursing profession and the health care system.
Keywords
community health nursing; community; Australia; nursing profession
References
Appleby F & Sayer L (2001): Public health nursing-health visiting. In Sines D, Appleby F, & Raymond E (eds.), Community health care nursing (2nd ed., pp. 115-132) Blackwell Science, Australia.
Baum F (1998): The new public health: an Australian perspective. Oxford University Press, Melbourne.
Bevis EO & Watson J (1989): Toward a caring curriculum: a new pedagogy for nursing. National League for Nursing, New York.
Brookes K (2003): Role Perceptions and Experiences of Community Health Nurses in a Contemporary Health Care System. Unpublished Bachelor of Nursing (Honours), Thesis University of Western Sydney. Sydney, Australia.
Coombes E (1989): An introduction to community health in Australia. In Rice V (ed.) Community Nursing Practice, (2nd ed. pp. 1-17) Sydney: MacLennan and Petty.
Davidson PM, Stewart S, Elliott D, Daly J, Sindone A, Cockburn J (2001):Addressing the burden of heart failure in Australia: the scope for home based interventions. Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing 16: 56-58.
Duckett SJ (2000): The Australian Health Care System, Oxford University Press, Melbourne.
Dunt DR, Temple-Smith, NJ & Johnson KA (1991): Nursing outside hospitals: the working experience of community nurses: job characteristics. International Journal of Nursing Studies 28 (1): 27-37.
Griffiths J & Luker K (1994): Community nurses attitudes to the clinical nurse specialist. Nursing Times 90 (17): 39-42.
Grosvenor J, Gleeson M & Ng K (1997): South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service Community Nursing Service Review. Unpublished manuscript.
Happell B (1998): Student nurses attitudes towards a career in community health. Journal of Community Health 23(4): 269-279.
Haste F & McDonald L (1992): The role of the specialist in community nursing: perceptions of specialist and district nurses. International Journal of Nursing Studies 29 (10): 37-47.
Heath P (2002): Our Duty of Care: National Review of Nursing Education. Departments of Education, Science and Technology, and Health and Ageing. Canberra
James T & Barker E (2001): Community Development. In Sines D, Appleby F and Raymond E (eds) Community Health Care Nursing, (2nd ed, pp.58-75). Blackwell Science Publishing, UK.
Jannings W & Maynard C (1998): Community nurses and their collaboration with clinical nurse consultants. Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 15(2): 12-16.
Jansen P, Kerkstra A, Abu Saad H, Van der Zee, J (1996): Models of differentiated practice and specialisation in community nursing: a review of the literature. Journal of Advanced Nursing 24(5): 968-980.
Jansen P, Kerkstra A, Abu Saad H, Van der Zee J (1997): Differentiated practice and specialisation in community nursing: a descriptive study in the Netherlands. Health and Social Care in the Community 5(4): 219-226.
Kendrick D Young A Futers D (2000): The diagnosis and management of acute childhood illness: is there a role for health visitors? Journal of Advanced Nursing 32(6): 1492-1498
Kerkstra A & Beemster F (1994): The quality of assessment visits in community nursing. Journal of Advanced Nursing 19: 1205-1211.
Koch, T. (2000). Nursing in the community. In Daly J, Speedy S & Jackson D (eds). Contexts of nursing: An introduction. MacLennan & Petty, Sydney.
Krosnick JA (1999): Survey Research. Annual Review of Psychology 50: 537-567.
Lauri S, Salantera S, Bild H, Chalmers K, Duffy M, Kim H (1997): Public health nurses decision making in Canada, Finland, Norway and the United States of America. Western Journal of Nursing Research 19(2): 143-165.
Layzell S & McCarthy M (1992): Specialist or generic community nursing care for HIV/AIDS patients. Journal of Advanced Nursing 18: 31-537.
Mann S & Byrnes T (2000): Bridging the gap. Collegian 7(3): 14-20.
Mason DJ, Knight K, Toughill E, Demaio D, Beck DL, Christopher MA (1992): Promoting the Community Health Nurse Specialist. Clinical Nurse Specialist, 6(1): 6-13.
McDonald AL, Langford IH, Boldero N (1997). The future of community nursing in the United Kingdom: district nursing, health visiting and school nursing. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 26(2), 257-265.
Mc Murray A (1992). Expertise in community health nursing. Journal of Community Health Nursing 9(2): 65-75.
Mead N, Bower P, Gask L (1997): Emotional problems in primary care: what is the potential for increasing the role of nurses. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 26(5): 879-890.
Mellon S & Nelson P (1998): Leadership experiences in the community for nursing students: redesigning education for the 21st century. Nursing & Health Care Perspectives 19(3): 120-3.
Motley J (1999): Community Nursing. In Pryor J (ed) Rehabilitation - a vital nursing function, (pp. 31-39). Deakin ACT: Royal College of Nursing Australia.
NSW College of Nursing Graduate Certificate in Community Nursing. Retrieved on 14th January 2003 from http://www.nursing.aust.edu.au/education/pdf_grad_cert/community_nursing.pdf
NSW Health Department (2001a). Improving health care for people with chronic illness. A blueprint for change 2001-2003. Retrieved on 14th January 2003 from http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/policy/gap/chronic/chroniccarereport.html
NSW Health Department (2001b) NSW Government action plan. Improving health care for people with chronic illness: A blueprint for change 2001-2003.
NSW Health (2002) http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/nursing/com.html accessed in April 2002.
Oberski I, Carter E, Gray M, Ross J (1999): The community gerontological nurse: themes from a needs analysis. Journal of Advanced Nursing 29(2): 454-462.
Pilkington W & Wood J (1986): Job satisfaction, role conflict and role ambiguity: A study of hospital nurses. Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 3(3): 3-14.
Purcell J (1990) Literature review of developments in nursing since 1985. Retrieved on 30th June, 2002 from http://www.clininfo.health.nsw.gov.au.hospolic/stvincents/1990
Senate Community Affairs Committee (2002). The Patient Profession: Time for Action. Report on the Inquiry into Nursing. Retrieved 17th September 2002 from http://www.aph.gov.au/Senate/committee/clac_ctte/nursing/report/index.htm
Smith J (2002) The changing face of community and district nursing. Australian Health Review 25(3): 131-133.
South Eastern Sydney Area Health Service (2001): Chronic and Complex Care Program Bulletin 1. http://www.sesahs.nsw.gov.au/csppint/Publications/Chronic%20disease%20projects/BULLETIN1.pdf. Retrieved 2 June 2003.
St John W (1998). Just what do we mean by community? Conceptualisations from the field. Health and Social Care in the Community 6(2): 63-70.
Zotti ME, Brown P, Stotts C (1996): Community based nursing versus community health nursing: what does it all mean. Nursing Outlook 44(5): 211-217.
eContent Home
