Withdrawal of treatment in the intensive care unit: The ethical and legal issues
Julianne KP Allen-Smyth
Student Nurse, Researcher (Honours), Curtin University of Technology, WA
PP: 070 - 082
Abstract
Many articles have been written and studies conducted into why our patients' pain is not being managed more effectively. The myths and fears still persist, yet the solution is known. Why, then, can't our profession help those we care most about - our clients?
Intensive care units (ICUs) have, over the last 30 years, become places of lifesaving miracles, and as such, moral dilemmas have also been created. As early as 1976, applications have been made to courts for the withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment (Wallace, 1995).The decision to withdraw treatment is one faced by health professionals every day in the ICU, and there are many legal and ethical issues to consider. The emotional, and other, stakes are also high in this area for patient, family and care team.
This paper discusses ethical and legal issues highlighting the principles, doctrines, legislation and precedents especially important in the making of the decisions to withdraw treatment. An ethical framework grid is suggested to assist with the decision-making process.
Keywords
intensive care; medical ethics; bioethics; life support
References
Ackermann RJ (2000) Withholding and withdrawing life-sustaining treatment. American Family Physician 62(7): 1555-1560.
Ad Hoc Committee of the Harvard Medical School to Examine the Definition of Brain Death (1999) A definition of irreversible coma. In Kuhse H & Singer P (eds) Bioethics: An Anthology, pp. 287-291. Blackwell Publishers, Oxford.
Alpers A & Lo B (1999) Avoiding family feuds: Responding to surrogate demands for life-sustaining interventions. Journal of Law, Medicine and Ethics 27(1) 74-83.
Author not specified (1995) The final autonomy. Editorial, The Lancet 346(8970): 259.
Balfour-Lynn IM & Tasker RC (1996) Futility and death in paediatric medical intensive care. Journal of Medical Ethics 22(5): 279-281.
Beauchamp TL & Childress JF (1994) Principles of Biomedical Ethics, Fourth Edition. Oxford University Press, New York.
Bennett P (1995) Cutting the thread of life: legal guidelines for the withdrawal of treatment following the Anthony Bland case. Care of the Critically Ill 11(2): 62-64.
Brahams D (1995) Parents seek right to allow boy in UK to die. The Lancet 346: 368.
Brody H, Campbell ML, Faber-Langendoen K & Ogle KS (1997) Withdrawing intensive life-sustaining treatment: Recommendations for compassionate clinical management. The New England Journal of Medicine 336(9): 652-657.
Burrows R (1994) Removal of life support intensive care units. Medicine and Law 13(5-6): 489-500.
Campbell ML, Bizek KS & Stewart R (1998) Integrating technology with compassionate care: Withdrawal of ventilation in a conscious patient with apnea. American Journal of Critical Care 7(2): 85-89.
Cogliano JF (1999) The medical futility controversy: Bioethical implications for the critical care nurse. Critical Care Nursing Quarterly 22(3): 81-88.
Daffurn K (1993) The role of the intensive care nurse - Their choice. Australian Critical Care 6(2): 10-15.
Daly BJ (1986) Critical care in nursing. In SJ Youngner (ed.) Human Values in Critical Care Medicine, pp. 123-148. Praeger, New York.
Daly BJ, Gorecki J, Sadowski A, Rudy EB, Montenegro HD, Song R & Dyer MA (1996) Do-not-resuscitate practices in the chronically critically ill. Heart and Lung 25(4): 310-317.
Davis AJ & Slater P (1988) Ethics in nursing: Implications for education and practice. Australian Nurses Journal 17(8): 18-20.
Dewland P & Dewland J (1999) At the coalface, but on the receiving end. Journal of Medical Ethics 25(6): 541-546.
Eccleston R (1996) God complexities. The Australian (April 20-21): 12-19.
Farrell MM & Levin DL (1993) Pediatric critical care: Brain death in the pediatric patient: Historical, sociological, medical, religious, cultural, legal, and ethical considerations. Critical Care Medicine 21(12): 1951-1965.
Forrell CR (1990) How We Are Governed: Federal State and Local Government. Longman Cheshire, Melbourne.
Gilligan T & Raffin TA (1995) Rapid withdrawal of support. Chest 108(5): 1407-1409.
Gilligan T & Raffin TA (1996) End-of-life discussions with patients: Timing and truth-telling. Editorial, Chest 109(1): 11-12.
Grossman SC & Wheeler K (1997) Predicting patients' deterioration and recovery. Clinical Nursing Research 6(1): 45-58.
Haddad A (1996) Ethics in action. RN 59(5): 21-23.
Hansen-Flaschen JH (1991) When life support is futile. Editorial, Chest 100(5): 1191-1193.
Harrigan P (1995) Doctors investigated for assisting suicide. The Lancet 346: 494.
Hawley G (1997) Ethics Workbook for Nurses: Issues, Problems and Resolutions. Social Science Press, New South Wales.
Inwald D, Jakobovits I, Petros A & Fisher M (2000) Education and debate: Brain stem death: Managing care when accepted medical guidelines and religious beliefs are in conflict. BMJ (The British Medical Journal) 320(7244): 1266-1270.
Johnstone M-J (1995) Bioethics: A Nursing Perspective, Second Edition. Harcourt Brace & Co., New South Wales.
Johnstone M-J (1999) Bioethics: A Nursing Perspective, Third Edition. Harcourt, Sydney.
Jones J & Cooke T (1996) Advanced life support: Role of the rural registered nurse. Australian Journal of Rural Health 4(2): 67-72.
Jones LC (1994) A right to die? Intensive and Critical Care Nursing 10: 278-288.
Jones T & Fitzgerald M (1998) Withdrawal of life support treatment: The experience of critical care nurses. Australian Critical Care 11(4): 117-121.
Kirkland L (1994) Neuromuscular paralysis and withdrawal of mechanical ventilation. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 5(1): 38-39.
Kollef MH (1996) Private attending physician status and the withdrawal of life-sustaining interventions in a medical intensive care unit population. Critical Care Medicine 24(6): 968-975.
Komesaroff PA & Cohen A (2001)The growth of ethics in medicine over the past 50 years. MJA (The Medical Journal of Australia) 174: 41-44.
Kuhse H & Singer P (1985) Should the Baby Live? The Problem of Handicapped Infants. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Lee DK, Swinburne AJ, Fedullo AJ & Wahl GW (1994) Withdrawing care: Experience in a medical intensive care unit. JAMA (The Journal of the American Medical Association) 271(17): 1358-1361.
Leech G (1998) Intensive care, extensive coolness: The shape of our health care system. The Australian (1 July): 4.
Marsee V (1994) Ethical dilemmas in the delivery of intensive care to critically ill oncology patients. Seminars in Oncology Nursing 10(3): 156-164.
Mason JK & Mulligan D (1996) Euthanasia by stages. The Lancet 347: 810-811.
Mitchell KR, Kerridge IH, et al. (1996) Bioethics and Clinical Ethics for Health Care Professionals, Second Edition. Social Science Press, New South Wales.
Murray LS, Teasdale GM, Murray GD, Jennett B, Miller JD, Pickard JD, Shaw MDM, Achilles J, Bailey S, Jones P, Kelly D & Lacey J (1993) Does prediction of outcome alter patient management? The Lancet 341: 1487-1491.
O'Callahan JG, Fink C, Pitts LH & Luce JM (1995) Neurologic critical care: Withholding and withdrawing life support from patients with severe head injury. Critical Care Medicine 23(9): 1567-1575.
Ohlenberg E (1996) We withdrew nutrition - not care. RN (May 1996): 36-40.
Osborne ML (1992) Physician decisions regarding life support in the intensive care unit. Chest 101(1): 217-224.
Pace NA (1996) Withholding and withdrawing medical treatment. In Pace NA & McLean SAM (eds) Ethics and the Law in Intensive Care, pp. 47-67. Oxford University Press, Oxford.
Peterson A (2000) Doctors left him for dead. The Daily Telegraph (Sydney, 30 December): 12.
Phelan D (1995) Hopeless cases in intensive care. Care of the Critically Ill 11(5): 196-197.
Pinch WJ & Parsons ME (1993) The ethics of treatment decision making: The elderly patient's perspective. Geriatric Nursing: American Journal of Care for the Aging 14(6): 289-293.
Plows CW, Tenery RM, Hartford A, Miller D, Morse L, Rakatansky H, Riccick FA, Ruff V, Wilkins G, Ile M, Munson J, Latham SR, Emanuel LL & American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs (1999) Medical futility in end-of-life care. JAMA (The Journal of the American Medical Association) 281(10): 937-942.
Raffin TA (1991) Biomedical ethics in the 1990s. Editorial, Chest 100(1): 4-6.
Ravenscroft AJ & Bell MDD (2000) End-of-life decision making within intensive care - objective, consistent, defensible? Journal of Medical Ethics 26(6): 435-440.
Riddick CA & Schneidermann LJ (1994) Distinguishing between effect and benefit. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 5(1): 41-42.
Savulescu J (1999) Rational desires and the limitation of life sustaining treatment. In Kuhse H & Singer P (eds) Bioethics: An Anthology, pp. 533-550. Blackwell Publishers, Oxford.
Schwartz RL (1999) Autonomy, futility and the limits of medicine. In Kuhse H & Singer P (eds) Bioethics: An Anthology, pp. 518-522. Blackwell Publishers, Oxford.
Singer P (1999) Is the sanctity of life ethic terminally ill? In Kuhse H & Singer P (eds) Bioethics: An Anthology, pp. 292-301. Blackwell Publishers, Oxford.
Swigart V, Lidz C, Butterworth V & Arnold R (1996) Letting go: Family willingness to forgo life support. Heart and Lung 25(6): 483-94.
Teres D (1993) Civilian triage in the intensive care unit: The ritual of the last bed. Critical Care Medicine 21(4): 598-606.
Thobaben M (1992) Whose life is it anyway? Client autonomy. Journal of Holistic Nursing 10(3): 240-250.
Truog RD (1999) Is it time to abandon brain death? In JD Arras & Steinbock B (eds) Ethical Issues in Modern Medicine, pp. 160-169. Mayfield Publishing Company, Mountain View, California.
Truog RD & Burns JP (1994) To breathe or not to breathe. The Journal of Clinical Ethics 5(1): 39-41.
Wall M (1995) Irish Supreme Court approves 'right-to-die' case. The Lancet 346: 368.
Wallace M (1995) Health Care and the Law, Second Edition. The Law Book Company, Sydney.
Wanzer SH, Federman DD, Adelstein SJ, Cassel CK, Cassem EH, Cranford RE, Hook EW, Lo B, Moertel CG, Safar P, Stone A & Eys JV (1989)The physician's responsibility toward hopelessly ill patients: A second look. The New England Journal of Medicine 320(13): 844-849.
Winter B. & Cohen S (1999) ABC of intensive care: Withdrawal of treatment. BMJ (The British Medical Journal) 319: 306-308.
eContent Home
