Evaluating a problem based learning course: An action research study
Jackie Walker
Clinical Nurse Specialist, Hospice and Palliative Care Service, Nurse Maude Association, Christchurch, New Zealand
Suzi Bailey
Lecturer, Mental Health Nursing, School of Nursing, Christchurch Polytechnic Institute of Technology, New Zealand
Robyn Brasell-Brian
Lecturer, Long Term Health Alteration Nursing, School of Nursing, Christchurch Polytechnic Institute of Technology, New Zealand
Sharon Gould
Lecturer, Mental Health Nursing, School of Nursing, Christchurch Polytechnic Institute of Technology, New Zealand
PP: 030 - 038
Abstract
Problem based learning (PBL) has been widely used in the United States, United Kingdom and Australasia in undergraduate nursing education to develop critical thinking and problem solving skills. PBL has been used since 1996 in a Bachelor of Nursing course at a New Zealand tertiary institution, and several modifications have been made to foster effective learning. The 'pure' PBL process has been adapted to gradually move students from teacher direction to taking responsibility for their learning. This has provided the opportunity for students to develop critical thinking, problem solving, information retrieval and evaluation skills, and group process skills over an 18-week period.
Because rigorous evaluation of these changes had not been formally undertaken, the purpose of this study was to evaluate how the current format was developing students' understanding and integration of knowledge. Two cycles of the action research method (Cardno & Piggot-Irvine, 1994) were used, involving 4 lecturers and 17 students. Data was collected both quantitatively and qualitatively over a 16-week period. Findings indicated the importance of: explaining the purpose and process of PBL; communicating in detail the role of both students and lecturers; keeping communication lines open; addressing timetabling issues and valuing this method of learning for nursing practice. Implications for nursing education are addressed.
Keywords
problem based learning; action research; evaluation of teaching
References
Biley FC, Smith KL 1998(a) Exploring the potential of problem-based learning in nurse education. Nurse Education Today 18(5): 353-361.
Biley FC, Smith KL 1998(b) 'The buck stops here': Accepting responsibility for learning and actions after graduation from a PBL nursing education curriculum. Journal of Advanced Nursing 27(5): 1021-1029.
Boud D, Felletti G (eds) (1996) The Challenge of Problem Based Learning, pp. 45, 66-70. Kogan Page Limited, London.
Brown BL (1998) Using problem-solving approaches in vocational education. Practice application brief. ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult, Career and Vocational Education, Colombus, Ohio.
Bunning C (1995) Professional development using action research. Unpublished manuscript. International Management Centre, Brisbane.
Cardno C, Piggot-Irvine E (1994) Action research - The key to successful senior management training in schools. Paper presented to NZARE Conference, Christchurch.
Christensen J (1990) Nursing Partnership: A Model for Nursing Practice. Daphne Brasell Associates, Wellington.
Conrick M (1994) PBL - Managing student transitions. In Chen SE, Cowdray RM, Kingsland AJ & Ostwald MJ (eds) Reflections on PBL. Australian PBL Network, Sydney.
Cooke M, Donovan A (1998) The nature of the problem: The intentional design of problems to facilitate different levels of student learning. Nurse Education Today 18(6): 462-429.
Creedy D & Hand B (1994) The implementation of problem-based learning: Changing pedagogy in nurse education. Journal of Advanced Nursing 20: 696-702.
Dods RF (1997) An action research study of the effectiveness of problem-based learning in promoting acquisition and retention of knowledge. Journal for the Education of the Gifted 20 4: 423-437.
Foote E (1997) Collaborative Learning in Community Colleges, p. 2. ERIC Clearinghouse for Community Colleges, Los Angeles.
Happell B (1998) Problem-based learning: Providing hope for psychiatric nursing? Nurse Education Today 18(5): 362-367.
Kaufman DM, Mann KV (1996) Comparing students' attitudes in problem-based and conventional curricula. Academic Medicine 71(10): 1096-1099.
Mammen M (1996) A survey of staff and student perceptions of the problem-based learning MBChB curriculum at Unitra. South African Journal of Higher Education 10(2): 175-184.
Mullins G (1994) The evaluation of teaching in a PBL context. In: Chen SE, Cowdray RM, Kingsland AJ & Ostwald MJ (eds) Reflections on PBL. Australian PBL Network, Sydney.
Schmidt HG (1995) The development of diagnostic competence: A comparison between a problem-based, an integrated and a conventional medical curriculum. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, San Francisco, April 18-22.
Shimoda TA, Takayesu JK (1997) Individual roles and group dynamics in a problem-based learning classroom: Generating and evaluating skill-oriented learning objectives. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago, March 24-28.
Vernon DTA (1995) Attitudes and opinions of faculty tutors about problem-based learning. Academic Medicine 70(3): 216-223.
Vernon DTA, Blake RL (1993) Does problem-based learning work? A meta-analysis of evaluative research. Academic Medicine 68(7): 550-563.
Woods D (1996) Problem based learning. In Boud & Feletti (eds) The Challenge of Problem Based Learning, pp. 123-127. Kogan Page Limited, London.
eContent Home
