Reflections on Benner: A critical perspective
Trudy Rudge
Professor of Nursing, Faculty of Nursing and Midwifery, University of Sydney, Sydney NSW
PP: 084 - 088
Abstract
This paper examines the theoretical perspective of Patricia Benner (1984; 1989) as outlined in two of her recent works. The evaluative criteria used are the critical perspective developed by Carr and Kammis (1986). The interpretive strengths of her work are identified and extended by comparison with the work of Lawler (1991).
Problems in Benner's analyses are found to centre around the weaknesses of the interpretive perspective. An analysis of the structural constraints that act to distort the interpretation of nurses' work is offered as an alternative. An evaluation is given of the relevance to practice of Benner's work.
References
Benner P and Benner RV (1979) The New Nurses' Work Entry: A troubled sponsorship. New York: Tiresias Press.
Benner P (1982) Issues in competency-based testing, Nursing Outlook 30(5): 303-309.
Benner P (1983) Uncovering the knowledge embedded in clinical practice, Image: Journal of Nursing Scholarship 15(2): 36-41.
Benner P (1984) From Novice to Expert: Excellence and power in clinical nursing practice. Menlo Park CA: Addison Wesley.
Benner P and Tanner C (1987) Clinical judgement: How expert nurses use intuition. American Journal of Nursing 87(1): 23-31.
Benner P and Wrubel J (1989) The Primacy of Caring: Stress and coping in health and illness. Menlo Park CA: Addison Wesley.
Bernstein R J (1976) The Restructuring of Social and Political Theory. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Bourdieu P (1971) Intellectual field and creative project, in Young M (ed) Knowledge and Control. London: Collier MacMillan, pp.161-188.
Bourdieu P (1973) Cultural reproduction and social reproduction, in Brown A, Knowledge, Education and Cultural Change. London: Tavistock, pp.71-112.
Bourdieu P (1977) Outline of a Theory of Practice. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Brykczynski KA (1989) An interpretive study describing the clinical judgement of nurse practitioners. Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice 3(2):75-104.
Carr W and Kemmis S (1986) Becoming critical: Knowing through action research. Victoria: Deakin University Press.
Diemert Moch S (1990) Personal knowing: Evolving research and practice. Scholarly Inquiry for Nursing Practice 4(2): 155-165.
Dolan K (1984) Building bridges between education and practice. In Benner P, From Novice to Expert: Excellence and power in clinical nursing practice.
Foucault M (1973) The Birth of the Clinic: An archaeology of medical perception. London: Tavistock.
Habermas J (1973) Theory and Practice. London: Heinemann.
Hardy LK (1988) Excellence in nursing through debate· The case of nursing theory. Recent Advances in Nursing 21: 1-13, Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Heidegger M (1982) Being and Time. New York: Harper.
Huntsman A et al (1984) Implementation of staff nurse at El Camino Hospital. In Benner P, From Novice to Expert: Excellence and power in clinical nursing practice.
Hutchinson S (1990) Responsible subversion: a study of rule-bending among nurses. Scholarly Inquiry tor Nursing Practice 4 (1): 3-17.
Lawler J (1990) Behind the Screens: Nursing, somology and the problem of the body. Melbourne: Churchill Livingstone.
Marriner-Tomey A (1989) Nursing Theorists and Their Work 2nd edn, St Louis: Mosby.
Marleau-Ponty M (1962) Phenomenology of Perception. London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Moccia P (1986) Theory development and nursing practice: A synopsis of a study of the theory-practice dialectic, in Moccia P (ed) New Approaches to Theory Development. New York: National League for Nursing, pp.23-38.
Pearson A (1989) Therapeutic nursing transforming models and theories in action, Recent Advances in Nursing 24: 123-151. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Polanyi M (1958) Personal Knowledge. London: Routledge Kegan Paul.
Rosaldo M (1973) Woman, culture and society: a theoretical overview. In Rosaldo M and Lamphere M (eds) Woman, Culture and Society. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Salvage J (1990) The theory and practice of the 'new nursing', Nursing Times 86(4): 42-45.
Silver M (1986) A program for career structure: From neophyte to expert. Australian Nurses' Journal 16(3): 38-41.
Walsh M and Ford P (1989) Nursing Rituals: Research and rational action. Oxford: Heinemann Nursing.
eContent Home
